General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsIdaho bans bumper nuts, topless beaches
This is the state's new indecent exposure statute:
https://legislature.idaho.gov/wp-content/uploads/sessioninfo/2025/legislation/H0270.pdf
18-4116. INDECENT EXPOSURE. (1) Every person is guilty of a misdemeanor if the person who willfully and lewdly, either:
10 (1) (a) Exposes his or her genitals,; exposes developed female breasts, including the areola and nipple; exposes adult male breasts, including the areola and nipple, that have been medically or hormonally altered to appear like developing or developed female breasts; exposes artificial breasts, including the areola and nipple, intended to resemble female breasts; or displays toys or products intended to resemble male or female genitals in any public place, or in any place where there is present another person or persons who are offended thereby; or
18 (2) (b) Procures, counsels, or assists any person so to expose his or her genitals,; to expose developed female breasts, including the areola and nipple; to expose adult male breasts, including the areola and nipple, that have been medically or hormonally altered to appear like developing or developed female breasts; to expose artificial breasts, including the areola and nipple, intended to resemble female breasts; or to display toys or products intended to resemble male or female genitals where there is present another person or persons who are offended thereby is guilty of a misdemeanor.

msongs
(70,953 posts)BOSSHOG
(41,760 posts)Imagine a group of wrinkled old white guys in a secure room in the state Capitol drafting this legislation.
mercuryblues
(15,510 posts)How many of them have man breasts?
Jerry2144
(2,743 posts)Theyre called moobs
dweller
(26,169 posts)Will be littered with the loosened bumpers for miles and miles upon the pristine sands
.
✌🏻
Wicked Blue
(7,750 posts)Blues Heron
(6,665 posts)get a life dudes, jeeziz
PedroXimenez
(646 posts)they're Nutz grabbers!
magicarpet
(17,872 posts)You can get away with it too if you are a Christo-Fascist.
Buns_of_Fire
(18,273 posts)Geez. Not even the Bible gets that granular. Again and again and again.
travelingthrulife
(1,921 posts)Ilsa
(62,647 posts)babies in public? Sometimes the nipple or areola is exposed, even accidentally.
Puritan hypocrites!
jmowreader
(52,051 posts)paleotn
(20,196 posts)

New bumper sticker...sorry Virginia.....Idaho is for fools.
chicoescuela
(1,924 posts)RainCaster
(12,469 posts)That so wrong... Every hick needs his nutz.
Norrrm
(980 posts)Sometimes indecent exposure is not that shocking.
unblock
(54,870 posts)Can't say how they'll enforce it, but afaik, topless beaches typically don't involve anyone exposing anything "lewdly".
If it comes to court, a lawyer could certainly argue that the law specifically includes that word to make it clear that non-lewd exposure is not a being banned.
Chellee
(2,242 posts)"...where there is present another person or persons who are offended thereby is guilty of a misdemeanor."
unblock
(54,870 posts)If it's not done willfully, it's not a misdemeanor. Full stop,
If it's not done lewdly, it's not a misdemeanor. Full stop.
That's 100% unambiguous from the construction if the sentence.
The word "lewdly" itself is subject to interpretation, but there's doubt that it applies. There would have to get a separate provision or a "notwithstanding the foregoing" part in order to override the earlier restriction that it has to be willfully and lewdly.
Chellee
(2,242 posts)any reasonably competent attorney should be able to argue that the statute doesn't apply to really anyone except flashers? People who are trying to shock and upset people with their nudity?
So toddlers that are 100% done with wearing their clothes, breastfeeding moms, people just sunbathing on the beach, wardrobe malfunctions, those people would be safe even if there was some deeply offended, overly pious, whack-a-doodle there calling down both the wrath of God, and the Idaho state legislature?
unblock
(54,870 posts)so in the end, they're not really banning being topless, they're banning certain actions and/or speech while topless.
trials may come down was she just walking or was she moving things suggestively.
Silent Type
(8,809 posts)DemocratSinceBirth
(100,788 posts)
maxsolomon
(36,154 posts)or Momos, or a combination of the 2.
Also: where are these beaches?
Jack Valentino
(1,701 posts)would ever move to Idaho in the first place---
and if she was born there, she would have emigrated by now.
Seems like another of those "performative bills" to me...
Cheezoholic
(2,832 posts)Kaleva
(39,099 posts)jmowreader
(52,051 posts)I live near Coeur dAlene and the beach at Coeur dAlene Lake is a big tourist attraction. In Sandpoint the same is true for Lake Pend Oreille. Youre only surfing at either one with a wakeboat, but you can do other beach stuff.
mackdaddy
(1,740 posts)Bare Bresticules and fake danglers were just corrupting the minds.
jmowreader
(52,051 posts)A Nampa city councilor named Sebastian Griffin went to Canyon County Pride one year (apparently so he'd have something to harrumph about at the next city council meeting) and saw a topless woman there. He tried to get the police to make her cover up or leave, and the cops told him what she was doing was legal.
Abolishinist
(2,347 posts)jmowreader
(52,051 posts)It is illegal in Idaho to have a strip club that serves liquor so, the one strip club up here has a bar next to it. Get juiced in the bar, go next door for the show.
tanyev
(45,882 posts)
jmowreader
(52,051 posts)We have big lakes and rivers here. There are many places along them that have beach-like sand that people use for such.
tanyev
(45,882 posts)Bet there arent many days in the year this Texas gal would consider hot enough to be beach-worthy.
Srkdqltr
(8,178 posts)Geeze Someone someplace had a good time writing.that.
jmowreader
(52,051 posts)Srkdqltr
(8,178 posts)



WestMichRad
(2,184 posts)
my excited she-male snowman, wouldnt it?
58Sunliner
(5,524 posts)jmowreader
(52,051 posts)The Idaho legislative session lasts months when they could get everything necessary done in a week. So, once they pass the budget, the tax cut, the bill relaxing gun laws and the anti abortion bill they run out of anything to do and start writing bills like this.
UpInArms
(52,421 posts)eom
J_William_Ryan
(2,583 posts)Could be a First Amendment violation, freedom of expression.
Otherwise, such is the authoritarian, fascist right.
Diraven
(1,332 posts)Random people can just walk in, claim they are offended from the sex toy displays, and then get them shut down.
wolfie001
(4,333 posts)Big time. Parking lots will be full of Idaho license plates
onethatcares
(16,737 posts)driving your megamaga coal hauling truck on the "Beaches of Idaho" while flaunting your areolas and nipples?
Funny thing though, I was just talking to a friend the other day and mentioned that I was going to take 2 weeks off in order to drive from Tampa Fl to the topless beaches of Idaho but they only have 3.4 hours of summer and I couldn't figure out which month that might be in so......................scratch that bucket list itme.
Emile
(33,677 posts)Mysterian
(5,486 posts)My guess.
jmowreader
(52,051 posts)When they put in the state line between Idaho and Utah it ran through Mormon country, so weve always had Mormons here.
milestogo
(20,060 posts)They are a sign of male insecurity for those who can't afford sports cars.
Renew Deal
(83,699 posts)
bluestarone
(19,321 posts)
Marthe48
(20,355 posts)get a muffler.
Tommy Carcetti
(43,816 posts)But I will admit "beaches" aren't the first thing that came to mind for me regarding Idaho.
underpants
(189,605 posts)GreenWave
(10,852 posts)
