General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsShould Canadians Consider Trump's Push for Statehood? - a WSJ lettet
Canadians for whom the future of the West, liberal democracy and the rules-based international order are important should consider leaning in to President Trumps obsession with making Canada the 51st U.S. state. Its population is roughly equal to Californias, and, given the countrys political center of gravity, it would probably be a solid blue state. Adding another one the size of California would put both the presidency and the House in the hands of the Democrats for decades to come.
Moreover, since no U.S. state is a federal entity like Canada, itd seem more sensible to have each province be admitted as a separate state, with two senators apiece. That would give the Democrats a filibuster-proof majority in the Senate and make their influence in the Electoral College even larger.
A U.S. enriched by Canadas temperate, sensible citizenry would be a more reliable leader of the free world. Perhaps, on reflection, Canadians would decide that lowering the maple-leaf flag is a price worth paying. More likely, Mr. Trumps supporters would persuade him to think again.
David Hoffman
https://www.wsj.com/opinion/should-canadians-consider-trumps-push-for-statehood-51st-271a0246?st=VAr9t9&reflink=desktopwebshare_permalink
free

Irish_Dem
(67,214 posts)Canada should not touch the US with a ten foot pole.
bucolic_frolic
(49,516 posts)The western oil rich provinces, for example, and the Maritime provinces. And Quebec has an independent streak and a legal system from France. And they don't exactly line up with our political boundaries.
I doubt Trump's idea could crack 22% if Canada held a referendum on it.
applegrove
(125,410 posts)Bernardo de La Paz
(53,901 posts)Scrivener7
(54,997 posts)Bernardo de La Paz
(53,901 posts)Solly Mack
(94,606 posts)riverbendviewgal
(4,342 posts)We like our diversity and freedom to read what we choose. We like our health regulations on food and water. We will never give up our universal health care for all. There are restrictions and regulations on guns. We pay higher taxes willingly to help fellow Canadians.
Canadians are kind and caring. But we will fight hard for our democracy as we did in the past. We went into WW2 in 1939 with the British. The USA took 2 years to get in.
Thank you Trump, You united all Canadians.
Elbows Up
We will readily drop our Gloves to protect our country and democracy.
We don't like bullies.
Paladin
(29,965 posts)struggle4progress
(122,329 posts)Bev54
(12,313 posts)We absolutely do NOT want to join US, so he can shove his opinion.
Bernardo de La Paz
(53,901 posts)Disaffected
(5,482 posts)The arrogance of these ridiculous people is astounding.