General Discussion
Related: Editorials & Other Articles, Issue Forums, Alliance Forums, Region ForumsCNN Data Guru Warns Trump Support Crashing: 'Absolute Collapse'
CNNs chief data analyst is sounding the alarm on President Donald Trumps abysmal poll numbers, saying they amount to an absolute collapse among key supporters.
CNNs Harry Enten said Trump, pushing 80, has watched his approval rating tank in recent months, with his disapproval hitting a record 62 percent as Republican-leaning Independents turn on him.
We are talking about a very important block [of voters] for the president of the United Statesthat is Republican-leaning Independents. That is whats going on," Enten said Monday.
At this point in Trumps first term, nearly three-quarters of Republican-leaning Independents supported him. Now, support has slipped to just half.
https://www.yahoo.com/news/articles/cnn-data-guru-warns-trump-195957808.html
kimbutgar
(27,487 posts)But I until I hear my MAGA BIL has turned on him hell still have power over the neurolinguistically programmed and they cant break away. Just like the Jim Jones cult members who share similarities to the 🍊🐖💩 supporters. ( sorry I just cant write his name)
BannonsLiver
(20,797 posts)erronis
(24,358 posts)Somehow someone has managed to sneak into some of those layers that aren't reached by rationale thinking.
J_William_Ryan
(3,547 posts)The blind partisan right will never abandon Trump.
pat_k
(13,790 posts)My theory: That 83% approval among Republicans is actually 83% of a shrinking number. When they extrapolate from samples, they make assumptions about the percentages in the population each group represents. The thing is, the percentage of Republicans has been declining quarter over quarter. I don't think pollsters are keeping up.
In other words, while the percentage approval among R's looks "stubborn" that percentage actually reflects fewer and fewer people. Conversely, the high percentage of disapproval among D's, even if it looks stable, actually represents more and more people.
Q1 2026 (ABC report of gallup numbers)
25% Republican
43% Independent
30% Democratic
Average across all quarters 2025 (Gallup)
27% Republican
45% Independent
27% Democratic
The difference from the average over 2025 my not look dramatic, but remember, when looked in the context of the past 23 years, you can see that the percentage of people who self-identify as Republicans has not been as low as it was in the first quarter of this year since 2013.

How dramatic the move is is seen very clearly when you add R+R leaning I's and D+D leaning I's.

Cirsium
(4,065 posts)Exactly right. "Such and such percentage of Republicans still support Trump" is misleading when the number of people identifying as Republican is shrinking.
pat_k
(13,790 posts)... the percentage of R's is bigger than it is.
The "gold standard" for party affiliation has long been gallup's annual number, which is released at the begining of each year based on interviews conducted over the course of the year.
It is tough to find quarterly numbers. They don't publish them -- at least not directly to the public that I can find. I was VERY surprised to see ABC's first quarter estimates from Gallup in that report.
I suspect they've been seeing a surprising downward trend since the felon took office. I think the first quarter numbers were reported because it has now become clear something "strange' is going on -- i.e., a big exodus. And it's been going on since the felon took office.
The thing is, i'm no expert, but it is my understanding that party affiliation is a very stable thing. It doesn't tend to change much within the same cohort. It does shift as young people are added and older people subtracted over longer periods of time.
So, if, on the assumption party affiliation is pretty stable, pollsters use the annual "gold standard" when they extrapolate from samples, rather than adjusting for every quarter, they are over-estimating his support because they are actually missing the "exodus."
erronis
(24,358 posts)But for about the last ten years I've seen/read people say that Trump's approval among Republicans is so high only because less people are staying Republican. That has yet to actually show up given gotten more votes every time he's run.
Granted midterms are different, but I am not convinced the GOP is really shrinking.
pat_k
(13,790 posts)Between 2015 and the last quarter of 2024, the trend was up and down so anyone saying it was consistently down wasn't looking at numbers.
The consistent downward trend took off after Q4 2024. Since then it has been a steady downward trend for six quarters. At no point prior to that since 2016 has the trend been the same direction for that many quarters. I find that significant.

Sure, maybe we shouldn't get too excited until the gap between D+D leaning I's and R+R leaning I's hits 15 points (that is, a bigger gap than any time since 1991), but I see the current trend as quite significant -- and a good sign. And while the current D+D leaning I's isn't as high as in 2008, I also find it significant that the number of R+R leaning I's is at the same low level of 39% -- lowest since 1991 at least.

They may not have been looking at actual figures, but I've read it dozens of times through the years.
many of the polls I have seen while showing Trump's numbers going down, those people are not going to the Democrats. They're either going to hold their noses and vote for Republicans, becoming "temporary" independents or thinking about sitting our certain elections.
Skittles
(172,537 posts)yes indeed
Tree Lady
(13,377 posts)Still vote republican in red states in November, I bet most of them.
BannonsLiver
(20,797 posts)erronis
(24,358 posts)Midnight Writer
(25,661 posts)He has nothing to offer but reality-show dramatic stunts. He doesn't know how to do anything but stir shit.
He is a conman who people are losing confidence in.
FoxNewsSucks
(11,901 posts)BannonsLiver
(20,797 posts)BannonsLiver
(20,797 posts)Ray Bruns
(6,628 posts)Were not even getting the bread.
Keepthesoulalive
(2,372 posts)Seems to be getting their attention, wait until the shortages hit. Maga who, what, I dont know no maga. As they run inside to hide their maga merch.
Skittles
(172,537 posts)stupid fucking morons
AZ8theist
(7,563 posts)But this analysis means shit unless it's a few days before the election.
I'm not convinced the Reich Wing doesn't have the fix in for the midterms.
usonian
(26,311 posts)Is stealing their sheep.
And it took these people how many years to find out?
Orrex
(67,323 posts)Often not soon enough.
travelingthrulife
(5,484 posts)leftyladyfrommo
(20,024 posts)He's getting just plain pathetic.
I saw a video of him giving a speech se
veral years ago and there isn't any comparison to him now. He had energy. Now he just wanders around abd his filter and judgement just aren't even there.
hibbing
(10,608 posts)BannonsLiver
(20,797 posts)paleotn
(22,573 posts)Stomp all over people's civil rights, gut government agencies that protect and serve all of us, kill Americans on the street in cold blood, and pilfer tax payer funding for personal gain.....get's little in the way of traction. But jack up their gas prices, not to mention their groceries, and they're fucking up in arms!!! I don't know whether to be happy or sad.
Mysterian
(6,597 posts)if the republicans retain control much longer.
Mysterian
(6,597 posts)The power of the billionaire-owned mass media propaganda is stunning and frightening.
Baitball Blogger
(52,637 posts)Even if he gets the money, it won't slow him down.
relogic
(210 posts)the proposed elation that maga/pukepubs support is in Absolute Collapse'. If this is collapse, I direct you to the significant victory of this regimes achievements the past year and a half.
As a symbol of what collapse means?
I present to you when he was allowed to put his name beside and on buildings, build ballrooms, construct towering arches to his name and destroy our gleaming Whitehouse I knew any talk of collapse is the lie out of hell literally.
Jirel
(2,381 posts)None of this matters unless we have (relatively) fair elections, and the numbers translate to removing sufficient fascists.
MineralMan
(151,495 posts)Now would be fine. Put it all behind you, Donnie!
dave99
(177 posts)GenThePerservering
(3,603 posts)in what beast of a world is that bad news?
Torchlight
(7,003 posts)I wouldn't be surprised to see even a few die-hard members of of fan club leadership in the legislatures begin to denounce him. Pump prices are not a theoretical concept nor a fictional anecdote to cover our narratives, but an occurrence we're forced to confront daily; and given the American proclivity to prioritize cash over conviction, I don't see this ending good for Mr. trump's base.
Kablooie
(19,118 posts)An absolute crash would require 90% the country to take their heads out of Trumps ass.
But they are all stuck in there so tight together that no one can pull out.
BannonsLiver
(20,797 posts)We are screwn!1111111111111111111111111111111
Kablooie
(19,118 posts)The number has barely budged.
BannonsLiver
(20,797 posts)80 is a bad number for him. I know Trump has so thoroughly routed a lot of folks so its hard to grasp that there may be an actual end to this. There is and its coming.
cstanleytech
(28,569 posts)BannonsLiver
(20,797 posts)Are we looking at a possible 3rd term for Donnie?
cstanleytech
(28,569 posts)BannonsLiver
(20,797 posts)Kablooie
(19,118 posts)If something,goes wrong always blame someone else, not Trump.
BlueTsunami2018
(5,047 posts)Well, 99% of the time anyway. Most people really dont give a shit what you do as long they feel good about the economy. President Biden was hammered relentlessly about the economy from the moment he took office until the day he left both by Piss and the corporate media. It didnt matter that we came out of Covid better than anyone, that inflation was under control, that significant investments were made in the country or that the stock market was doing well. People didnt feel like the economy was doing well and so they let that imbecile back into power on his absurd promises. All the other stuff was peripheral.
Fast forward to now and the economy really does suck. Average Joe is really paying the price at the pump and at the grocery store and every other aspect of his life. People dont care about this war except that its sending the price of gas through the roof. If it had worked like Piss said it would, people would be fine with it.
Most voters dont get into the minutiae of politics, they care about what they can see and feel. And their wallets are taking a beating.
And thats why the Republicans are going to get dog walked in November.
EnergizedLib
(3,113 posts)Almost every Republican who voted against gerrymandering is losing right now to a MAGAt challenger.
Red Mountain
(2,376 posts)I can go to a state website, type in a name and see how that person is registered. It shows what elections and primaries they have voted in for the last 20+ years.
It seems to me few people are aware of this.
Independents that always vote in republican primaries......are registered as independents because they think they are flying under the radar. At some point they were unwilling to commit in person. First time registering, getting a drivers license, whatever. They didn't want to say a party name at the time......but are steady voters for republican candidates.
At this point anybody registered as an independent and willing to entertain the thought of voting for trump or his minions is anything but independent.
Don't get me started on registered Democrats who vote republican. They exist around here still.
Anyway.......was wondering......does your state have a voter lookup like this?
https://vt.ncsbe.gov/reglkup/
sakabatou
(46,262 posts)mdbl
(8,729 posts)He'll just call it fake news.