Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

JMCKUSICK

(1,726 posts)
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 01:26 PM Mar 19

My Disability claim has been denied

I got home from the Montgomery County Democratic meeting and had another E-mail from SSA.
It's been really really demoralizing even though my lawyer told me to expect it because it involves my back. (almost all back related disability claims get denied)
I've spent all morning on the phone with my lawyer and we've already filed the appeal. I just fear that there will be a further gutting of services and therefore cause longer delays. H guessed that the process to get in front of a judge, after reconsideration etc.. will be 7-8 months.
It is really hard to keep a healing and positive energy base as this goes on but I promise, I will try. I'm praying and meditating, I'm celebrating all of you being my spiritual support family and trying to treat this as expected and to roll with the punches.
My breathing is going real well, consistently over 2500 on the incentive thingy. I'm taking Cuddles back to the cemetery again this afternoon for our special time and really grateful that I have the walker chair because there's no way I'd make it otherwise.
My back is a real struggle as i have to lie down as soon as my walks are over to alleviate the pain that I have from almost any movement.
The good news is I had 60 days to appeal and it got done day one. So no unnecessary delays. I do appreciate my lawyer spending more than 3 hours doing that with me by phone.
I love you guys, please stay with me.
John Mckusick

55 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
My Disability claim has been denied (Original Post) JMCKUSICK Mar 19 OP
Sorry to hear, John. SheltieLover Mar 19 #1
I know that SSA assigns cases to states.... JMCKUSICK Mar 19 #6
Yw SheltieLover Mar 19 #8
I'm so sorry. I've heard from others, it takes three attempts and a good lawyer to get disability approved, so LiberalLoner Mar 19 #2
My friend spent 3 yrs appealing womanofthehills Mar 19 #3
I'm glad she finally won and got the back pay too! 💙 LiberalLoner Mar 19 #5
I've got plenty to be thankful for LiberalLoner JMCKUSICK Mar 19 #7
💙💙💙💙🌹🌹🌹🌹 LiberalLoner Mar 19 #14
I'm trying not to, the whole system is designed to JMCKUSICK Mar 19 #21
My husband was denied twice. pandr32 Mar 19 #29
Sorry to hear mvd Mar 19 #4
Well, let's have a GOOD LUCK to both of us eh? JMCKUSICK Mar 19 #22
Very sorry this is going on., John. debm55 Mar 19 #9
Thank you Debbie, you are such a supportive friend. JMCKUSICK Mar 19 #10
Best of luck to you. xuplate Mar 19 #11
Thank you xuplate JMCKUSICK Mar 19 #35
Arg so sorry to hear this. Yeah, I know this is often the pattern... electric_blue68 Mar 19 #12
Mine has the hose and then the 0-4000 JMCKUSICK Mar 19 #23
Bummer. Good luck on the appeal and I hope it doesn't take 7-8 months. Stay strong. LoisB Mar 19 #13
Thank you LoisB JMCKUSICK Mar 19 #24
Keep appealing meow2u3 Mar 19 #15
I like your plan JMCKUSICK Mar 19 #25
So sorry you are going through this, John. Please know that we love you, too, and are right there with you. wordstroken Mar 19 #16
Thank you wordstroken JMCKUSICK Mar 19 #26
That's the way they like to deny benefits Nigrum Cattus Mar 19 #17
Agreed Nigrum Cattus JMCKUSICK Mar 19 #36
Social Security does NOT PoindexterOglethorpe Mar 19 #18
So true. piddyprints Mar 19 #30
Bingo! PoindexterOglethorpe Mar 19 #33
I should be careful with my words JMCKUSICK Mar 19 #37
Oh that is bad news but know that we are all here for you Jim. Your attitude is terrific and great for healing. Nanuke Mar 19 #19
Hi Nanuke JMCKUSICK Mar 19 #38
I am so sorry you have to go through this, John. sheshe2 Mar 19 #20
Thank you sheshe2 JMCKUSICK Mar 19 #39
The big secret: they will turn it down a second time and rule for you the third time ... marble falls Mar 19 #27
Myth, myth, myth. PoindexterOglethorpe Mar 19 #34
Experiance, experiance, experiance ... marble falls Mar 19 #40
Experiance? PoindexterOglethorpe Mar 19 #41
Really sorry Wifes husband Mar 19 #28
Thank you Wife's husband JMCKUSICK Mar 20 #45
I'm so sorry. piddyprints Mar 19 #31
Thank you piddyprints JMCKUSICK Mar 20 #46
In the meantime ... Dorothy V Mar 19 #32
Thank you Dorothy JMCKUSICK Mar 20 #47
Good luck. Rizen Mar 19 #42
Thank you Risen. JMCKUSICK Mar 20 #48
Sorry about the ss denial. Good thing you have a lawyer. Clouds Passing Mar 19 #43
Hmmm, thank you CP JMCKUSICK Mar 20 #49
Appeal & don't give up UTUSN Mar 19 #44
I had back pain, too and Chalco Mar 20 #50
I always heard that they always deny the claim ArnoldLayne Mar 20 #51
k&r n/t area51 Mar 22 #52
We are family John. and we will stand with you. debm55 Mar 22 #53
Thank you Debbie, JMCKUSICK Mar 22 #54
Good luck to you. OldBaldy1701E Mar 22 #55

SheltieLover

(65,739 posts)
1. Sorry to hear, John.
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 01:32 PM
Mar 19

Be glad you're in IL.

Here in TN, I've been told people are denied 5 or 6 times before approved.

It's a fed progeam, so I don't know what the state has to do with it. Maybe just asshole magats processing things here?

I hope it gets favorably resolved quickly! I'm glad your lawyer got it done on day 1!

JMCKUSICK

(1,726 posts)
6. I know that SSA assigns cases to states....
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 02:21 PM
Mar 19

I just hope this doesn't keep dragging out, you all know what a struggle this last year and a half it's been already.
Thank you for your kind words SheltieLover.

LiberalLoner

(10,856 posts)
2. I'm so sorry. I've heard from others, it takes three attempts and a good lawyer to get disability approved, so
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 01:44 PM
Mar 19

Please don’t lose hope. 🙏💙

womanofthehills

(9,605 posts)
3. My friend spent 3 yrs appealing
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 02:05 PM
Mar 19

3rd judge gave it to her. Then she got all the back money- $30 thousand from first applying.

JMCKUSICK

(1,726 posts)
7. I've got plenty to be thankful for LiberalLoner
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 02:23 PM
Mar 19

your words amongst them.
I just want to see a light at the end of this tunnel.

JMCKUSICK

(1,726 posts)
21. I'm trying not to, the whole system is designed to
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 05:27 PM
Mar 19

Make you quit. I swear.
You all have been here holding me up spiritually and emotionally. I can't let that energy go to waste

pandr32

(12,785 posts)
29. My husband was denied twice.
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 05:56 PM
Mar 19

He was finally approved on the third doctor visit (their doctors).

mvd

(65,609 posts)
4. Sorry to hear
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 02:12 PM
Mar 19

I know it so often happens the first time. It did with me. I finally found a lawyer who is willing to take my case again - it isn’t mom’s lawyer’s specialty, but she can help.

xuplate

(36 posts)
11. Best of luck to you.
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 03:07 PM
Mar 19

After suffering back pain, and one bout of sciatica, for years I started doing stretches for the back and hips. About 20 minutes most days of the week has brought amazing relief. They are boring but effective. No more groaning when I empty the bottom row of the dishwasher.

electric_blue68

(20,603 posts)
12. Arg so sorry to hear this. Yeah, I know this is often the pattern...
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 03:10 PM
Mar 19

. it still sucks!
And I didn't know this about back injuries.

I hope it will be resolved in your favor, and sooner than you expect.

Great news about your breathing!!
My mom became severely asthmatic when I was about 5 ish years old. So I've seen bad breathing problems.

What's this breathing test device you are using? I think post 2 surgeries I had the simple one: plastic, rectangular "case", transparent, ?4 tubes w balls in a row. You blew in and if your breathing was excellent all 4 would quickly float to the top of each of their tube.
If it varied depending by how much in each tube the ball stayed lower how difficult it was.

By the number you describe it sounds quite different.

JMCKUSICK

(1,726 posts)
23. Mine has the hose and then the 0-4000
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 05:31 PM
Mar 19

Measure with the green circular thing that I have to keep in mind range to keep my breathing regular.
It's called an Incentive Spirometer

meow2u3

(25,117 posts)
15. Keep appealing
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 03:34 PM
Mar 19

Social Security always seems to deny initial disability claims. You just keep appealing--and appealing, armed with the truth and your doctors as witnesses, until your claim is granted. You have to nag the shit out of the authorities until you've pestered them so much they'll grant your claim just to get you off their case.

wordstroken

(932 posts)
16. So sorry you are going through this, John. Please know that we love you, too, and are right there with you.
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 03:40 PM
Mar 19

Nigrum Cattus

(450 posts)
17. That's the way they like to deny benefits
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 03:48 PM
Mar 19

Keep trying and fight back !
They (republicans) are now a death cult.
We are beginning to understand their "demands" and can now develop a plan to fight back

PoindexterOglethorpe

(27,644 posts)
18. Social Security does NOT
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 04:13 PM
Mar 19

always deny a first claim. Most people do not understand just how thoroughly their disability needs to be documented. Not just a couple letters from a doctor, but detailed information about what the person can and cannot do.

I used to work for a disability claims attorney and saw this first hand. I also spent literal hours at the local Social Security office photocopying massive files. There is also a presumption that a person may well be able to work at an equivalent job, which can result in denial.

The other thing is that the appeals attorney will not charge you, or take money from your settlement. They get paid separately, and how much they get is set by federal law.

piddyprints

(14,912 posts)
30. So true.
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 08:00 PM
Mar 19

I was lucky. My doc’s mantra was, “Document, document, document.” And I mean he wrote down everything.

I was approved on the first try.

PoindexterOglethorpe

(27,644 posts)
33. Bingo!
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 08:59 PM
Mar 19

I think people think that just a doctor's letter or two will be good enough, but it's not.

The other problem is that a lot of people who think they ought to get SSDI, simply are not qualified for it.

On the other hand, going blind gets you on SSDI immediately. My brother went blind at age 50, and was approved very quickly.

JMCKUSICK

(1,726 posts)
37. I should be careful with my words
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 09:12 PM
Mar 19

When I filed, my attorney said I should plan on being denied because back issues and mental health claims are the two most likely to involve fraud.

Nanuke

(692 posts)
19. Oh that is bad news but know that we are all here for you Jim. Your attitude is terrific and great for healing.
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 04:13 PM
Mar 19

sheshe2

(90,990 posts)
20. I am so sorry you have to go through this, John.
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 04:29 PM
Mar 19

Hugs. We are here for you when you need us.

marble falls

(64,325 posts)
27. The big secret: they will turn it down a second time and rule for you the third time ...
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 05:35 PM
Mar 19

... this how it goes for unemployment, welfare, SS ... etc. Having the lawyer is icing on the cake.

PoindexterOglethorpe

(27,644 posts)
34. Myth, myth, myth.
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 09:04 PM
Mar 19

They do NOT automatically turn down everyone the first time they apply.

The reason most people are turned down at first is, as I've already pointed out, they do not provide the needed documentation. Which is a LOT of documentation. Most people simply don't read the SS website to learn just how much documentation they need to provide.

Plus, what the hell are you claiming this how it goes for unemployment, welfare, SS . So tell me all about the people who are turned down for unemployment, welfare, and Social Security.

marble falls

(64,325 posts)
40. Experiance, experiance, experiance ...
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 09:24 PM
Mar 19

... short of fraud or actually not having six months on the job in the last year, or actually being injured off the job - three tries and your in. Particularly in Osha or SSDI having a lawyer makes all the difference.

To be clear: fraud is a crime. Do not be a criminal.

PoindexterOglethorpe

(27,644 posts)
41. Experiance?
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 09:31 PM
Mar 19

Trust me, people haven't a clue just how much documentation they need. So, I'm guessing what you mean by "Experiance, experiance, experiance." is that it took you at least three times to get all that documentation.

Oh, and it's "experience".

Wifes husband

(415 posts)
28. Really sorry
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 05:50 PM
Mar 19

Back trouble is the worst. You cannot get away from it, no matter how you move. The pain just wears you down.

I hope you get better

JMCKUSICK

(1,726 posts)
45. Thank you Wife's husband
Thu Mar 20, 2025, 12:02 AM
Mar 20

Been going on since August of 1996. Bad in last seven or eight years, and really bad in last four.

Dorothy V

(275 posts)
32. In the meantime ...
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 08:17 PM
Mar 19

I refuse to believe there is nothing they can do to help alleviate that pain, at least to a point it's easier to handle. Keep pestering your docs about it. Also, I like xuplate's suggestion for stretching exercises. Listening to music might help them be less boring (my problem with mere exercise). Getting fitted for a back brace might be a good idea as well.
Sounds like you got a good lawyer! Happy for you on that!
Of course we're staying with you! We're all family!

JMCKUSICK

(1,726 posts)
47. Thank you Dorothy
Thu Mar 20, 2025, 12:06 AM
Mar 20

I'm more than willing try new things or methods. Let's just say I haven't had much luck.

Clouds Passing

(4,239 posts)
43. Sorry about the ss denial. Good thing you have a lawyer.
Wed Mar 19, 2025, 10:21 PM
Mar 19

Awesome your breathing is improving and you're walking. Even with a walker it’s better than not walking. Do the simple lower back exercises and stretches but gently, breathe into the pain area as you are doing the workout. Keep it short.

We will all help you stay positive with our encouragement, praise, comfort and good advice 💚

Chalco

(1,395 posts)
50. I had back pain, too and
Thu Mar 20, 2025, 01:25 PM
Mar 20

going to the gym helped a lot. I go to Planet Fitness ($11/month) and they have
cardio equipment which I use but also lots of machines with weights for developing muscles.

There are several machines that work on back muscles. Before doing this I couldn't stand up for more than an hour without feeling extreme pain in my lower back. Now
I can stand up for 4 hours.

You might want to try this while you're waiting for the judgement.

P.S. I'm 76.

ArnoldLayne

(2,203 posts)
51. I always heard that they always deny the claim
Thu Mar 20, 2025, 04:17 PM
Mar 20

the first time. Then file an appeal with an Attorney the second time then they ok it.

OldBaldy1701E

(7,545 posts)
55. Good luck to you.
Sat Mar 22, 2025, 09:11 PM
Mar 22

I tried twice and they told me to shove it both times because my husband is over the income minimum by a few hundred bucks. We are soon to be facing homelessness and there seems to be little anyone can do about that either. With the current administration on its rampage, there is little hope for myself. Maybe you can get something.

Latest Discussions»The DU Lounge»My Disability claim has b...