Pumpkin pie is a tradition at Thanksgiving meals., but what other pies would you or have you served? Mine would be

[debm55]

Apple.

[EYESORE 9001]

1. Pecan pie or something close to it

[debm55]

7. Oh yes, terrific. Thank you very much, EYESORE 9001, And enjoy.

[RainCaster]

2. Apple and blackberry

And coffee of course!

[debm55]

9. Great. Thank you very much for sharing with us.RainCaster. That sounds delicious.

[Emile]

3. Coconut Cream

[debm55]

10. Yummy. thank you Emile. I haven't had Coconut Cream in a long time. Thank you for the memories.

[Dulcinea]

30. One of my favorites!

There used to be a restaurant near me that made coconut cream pie. I miss it!

[2naSalit]

4. Not a fan of pumpkin pie...

I usually make apple and pecan, anybody wants something else, they can make it themselves.

[debm55]

20. HAHAHAHAHAH. Thank you very much, 2naSalit. I like your spirit. and I like apple and pecan

[SheltieLover]

5. French Silk, Peppermint Cream, Blueberry...

Ty he possibilities are endless.

[debm55]

21. Thank you SheltieLover. Your choices of pies are fantastic.

[electric_blue68]

84. While looking up a different pie I found that the French Silk is a chocolate type of pie? If so; count me in!

😄

[markodochartaigh]

6. Millionaire pie,

with or without cherries. Quick, delicious, easy, no-bake, and healthy. Well, four out of five anyway.

[debm55]

22. HAHAHAHAHAH. Wonderful. Thank you very much, markodochartaigh. Four out of five isn't bad.

[yourout]

8. Cherry, Apple, peach, rhubarb... All good

[debm55]

23. You are so right, They are all good choices. Thank you yourout

[leanforward]

78. Pecan

[debm55]

81. Thank you leanforward, Great pie.

[Polly Hennessey]

11. Pecan and Mincemeat (with hard sauce).

[debm55]

24. Thank you very much, Polly Hennessey. They are both unique and delicious.

[Keepthesoulalive]

12. Sweet potato

A pie of the Deep South.

[unc70]

17. I'm with you. Sweet potato pie

So much better than pumpkin pie.

[debm55]

25. Thank you very much, Keepthesoulalive. I actually like sweet potato pie better then pumpkin. Enjoy.

[Walleye]

13. Apple and rhubarb

[debm55]

26. Thank you very much for your choices, Walleye. Will you be making them for Thanksgiving? Enjoy.

[PoindexterOglethorpe]

14. Mince pie.

Never liked pumpkin myself.

[debm55]

28. Thank you very much, PoindexterOglethorpe, for sharing with us. Enjoy your mince pie.

[TommieMommy]

15. Apple sometimes pumpkin cheesecake

[debm55]

29. OOOOHHHH. pumpkin cheesecake. YUMMY. Thank you very much. TommieMommy. It is delicious.

[CincyDem]

16. What else...a SECOND pumpkin pie. :-)

[debm55]

33. HAHAHAHHAHHA. Thank you very much, CincyDem. You like your pumpkin pie, I see. Enjoy.

[mike_c]

18. pecan pie

I don't care for pumpkin pie.

[debm55]

47. Thank you very much, mike_c. I love pecan pie too

[OldBaldy1701E]

19. We would have Pecan pie, Peach pie, and Blackberry cobbler. (n/t)

[debm55]

48. Wonderful, Thank you for sharing with us. Lots of desserts. Yummy.

[Trueblue Texan]

27. pecan.

A liquor store chain in Texas (Spec's) sells a bourbon pecan pie during the holidays...FABULOUS!

[debm55]

49. Thank sounds absolutely wonderful. Enjoy, Trueblue Texan.

[MIButterfly]

31. I could never have another. I LOVE pumpkin pie.

[debm55]

50. Thank you very much, MlButterfly. Wonder pumpkin pie

[JMCKUSICK]

32. Mincemeat or banana cream pie

[debm55]

52. Thank you very much, John. Both are great. Enjoy.

[Dulcinea]

34. My favorite Thanksgiving pie is pumpkin with whipped topping...

Last edited Mon Nov 17, 2025, 12:33 PM - Edit history (1)

...but I also supply pecan pie & a baby apple pie for my husband because it's his favorite. That may sound like a lot of pie, but it never goes to waste!

[debm55]

54. That is very kind and sweet of you, Dulcinea. Thank you for sharing with us.

[lark]

35. Home made pecan pie is the queen of pies at our house.

We also love Dutch Apple Crumb Pies, both homemade of course!

When mom was alive she made these awesome peanut butter pies that were to die for, but they were difficult to make with a homemade custard, and no one else loves them like I do so those have gone away - sadly!

[debm55]

56. Thank you very much, lark. Both of your choices are terrific. The peanut butter pies were great because your mother

added a special ingredient----love. May the memories of your mom, bring you blessings.

[yorkster]

36. Pumpkin, apple, and mince.

Mince pie with coffee in the am. Yum.
Or the recipe on the back of the mincemeat jar - mincemeat for the bottom half of the.pie and apple for the top.

[debm55]

57. Thank you very much for sharing with us, yorkster. Your choices are wonderful

[pandr32]

37. Maple Walnut.

I am Canadian born, so it is my preferred alternative to pecan. No corn syrup--just 100% maple syrup instead, and lots of toasted walnuts giving it a heavenly crunch. TO DIE FOR!!!

[electric_blue68]

46. Oooo, never heard of this!

[debm55]

58. Wow, thank you pandr32, I am unfamiliar with this type of pie. but it sounds soooo good.

Last edited Mon Nov 17, 2025, 09:01 PM - Edit history (1)

[pandr32]

85. It is really good! I will be making some soon!

[patphil]

38. Apple definitely.

I grew up in upstate New York. That's apple country, and we would go apple picking every fall. I remember my mother, sister and I sitting in front of the TV watching football on the Sunday before Thanksgiving peeling apples while my older sister baked pies in the kitchen, with the smell of apple pie wafting through the house.
Ah, fond memories.

[AltairIV]

45. i completely agree with you. Apple Pie is King!

[debm55]

59. Oh patphil, that sounds so wonderful. And the smell of baking apple pies. Terrific. thank you so much for sharing your

memories with us.

[John Coktosten]

39. Pie

Just as a default setting, I love almost ALL pies. 😃 If y'all could see my fat ass in person, that would be obvious. 🤣
Here in the south, we also serve sweet potato pie for Turkey Day.
But seriously, how can you go wrong with other pies? Blueberry, strawberry, rhubarb, peach, apple, pecan, key lime, lemon meringue, etc., etc., etc......is there a bad pie?
😎

[debm55]

60. Thank you very much for your post. You are so right, all pies are great, That is of course if I make from scratch.

[John Coktosten]

79. 😊

😊

[no_hypocrisy]

40. Apple Cheesecake

[debm55]

61. Oh my, that sounds great. Thank you so much for sharing with us, no_hypocrisy. Wonderful

[Emile]

41. Peanut Butter Pie

[debm55]

62. Oh wow, Emile, I want a slice. Now!!!! What is the filling made of?

[pnwest]

42. Marie Callender's Dutch Apple pie and Pecan pie.

… would round out my trio of pie perfection.

[debm55]

64. Thank you very much, pnwest, Your choices are great. I buy the Marie Callender's Dutch Apple ---yummy.

[Redleg]

43. Rhubarb for me

My family likes pecan pie, which is fine but not my favorite.

[debm55]

65. Thank you very much for sharing with us, Redleg.Your selection is wonderful. Enjoy.

[fargone]

44. Lemon chess with whipped cream

[debm55]

66. Oh, that sounds great, Thank you for sharing, fargone. It sounds very unique and delicious.

[OLDMDDEM]

51. Peach cobbler.

[debm55]

68. OHHHH. thank you very much, OLDMDDEM, I like mine with vanilla ice cream on top. Enjoy.

[OLDMDDEM]

69. That does sound good to me.

[Coldwater]

53. Mincemeat pie

was always the third choice at my Thanksgiving Day table

[debm55]

67. Thank you very much, Coldwater for sharing the mincemeat pie, Enjoy.

[Historic NY]

55. Indian pudding

there are several recipes. Its connection to Indians is thats its Indian corn meal.
milk, butter, molasses, eggs, spices, and cornmeal. I have made it several times its best when its baked long and on low heat. Most packets of corn meal have a recipe on it.

Pumpkin pie consistence, but better.

[debm55]

70. Thank you very much for sharing with us, Historic NY. That sounds wonderful I used to make a dish called corn pudding

With cornbread and corn. I stopped making because no one ate it except me.

[yorkster]

72. Hot Indian pudding with vanilla ice cream...

[woodsprite]

63. Mincemeat is a family favorite.

But we also will have pumpkin, cherry, and egg custard pies.

[debm55]

71. Thank you very much for your choices. woodsprite. I haven't had egg custard in ages and I loved it.

[rsdsharp]

73. Pecan. This year we're also trying Impossible Apple Cake.

And we’re doing Pumpkin Mousse.

[debm55]

75. Thank you rsdsharp. What wonderful choices. Can I come to your house for dessert???

[rsdsharp]

80. Any time, my friend.

[Dorothy V]

74. Pecan Pie and Peach Cobbler

I don't care that much for pecan pie, it's too rich. But my guys love them and I've made so many over the years that I expect I could make one blindfolded and one hand tied behind my back.

[debm55]

77. Thank you very much for sharing with us, Dorothy V, You are very kind to make them for your guys. Peach Cooble is good

too, I like with vanilla ice cream on top.

[Lithos]

76. Strawberry Rhubarb

Nothing finer.

[debm55]

82. Thank you very much, Lithos. Yes, an excellent pie.

[electric_blue68]

83. Don't remember much about pies. My current choices would be...

Chocolate Cream, pecan, apple, or coconut cream.

A then nyc (late '80's) small pie company made a ?sour cream walnut apple pie. Oh, it was sooo good! But when they got bigger they changed it. Not as good.

I wish I liked key lime, but it's too strong for me. (like regular limes)

Some people add chocolate, or chocolate chips to their pecan pie! Yum.

[debm55]

86. Thank you very much, electric_blue68. I have had pecan pie with chocolate chips. Delicious

[electric_blue68]

87. Ooh, yum! 😄

[debm55]

88. Yes indeed it is

[PufPuf23]

89. Think pumpkin, mincemeat and pecan pies as trad Thanksgiving pies.

Growing up with family saw apple but also less common lemon meringue and huckleberry.

[debm55]

90. Thank you very much PufPuf23. for sharing with us.Enjoy

[ProfessorGAC]

91. Pecan

For a cold pie, coconut cream.

[debm55]

92. Thank you ProfessorGAC, Two wonderful and delicious pies

[Wolf Frankula]

93. Pecan pie

Peach pie. I don't eat pumpkins.

[debm55]

94. Thank you very much, Wolf Frankula. Enjoy.