Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

happybird

(5,113 posts)
Mon May 27, 2024, 08:02 PM May 2024

One of my Catbird friends asked for help!

There is a pair who have made a nest in the shrub next to my lower deck. They are my buddies and will let me talk to them as they perch on the railings of the upper deck/porch.

I was sitting on the couch on the upper deck in a Zoom meeting and one kept loudly calling while the other was zooming around from tree to tree in the yard. The calls sounded different from their familiar vocalizations: very insistent and a different pitch. I took a quick photo of the one yelling in my direction and came down to the lower deck. A big fat grey and white cat was on the railing, inside their bush! It jumped down and ran away when I came down the steps.





This is their shrub, and the cat was lurking on the railing by the grill, inside the shrub. Didn't even see it till it jumped down.

Normally I am happy for cats to be in my yard, but I've never had bird friends before, so this year is different! Is there anything I can do to discourage this cat away from the shrub, something that won't scare the birds?

20 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
One of my Catbird friends asked for help! (Original Post) happybird May 2024 OP
cayenne? Tetrachloride May 2024 #1
I worry that would get on the birds' feet, too happybird May 2024 #3
Birds are generally much less sensitive to hot peppers than mammals RockRaven May 2024 #9
Thank you! happybird May 2024 #11
PLEASE don't use cayenne around birds, nestlings, and pollinators because you'll cause more harm Donkees May 2024 #18
Thank you happybird May 2024 #19
They are also fond of raisins, bite-sized chopped apple, seeded multigrain sliced bread pieces ... Donkees May 2024 #20
Cats aren't welcome in my yard, at all. dem4decades May 2024 #2
I am a cat lover and enjoy visits from Willie, the black cat who lives down the road happybird May 2024 #6
We feed birds, cats are killers, they kill song birds. dem4decades May 2024 #10
I agree happybird May 2024 #13
We have an occasional bear, we have plants that attract the hummers. dem4decades May 2024 #14
WOWOWOWOWOW!!! elleng May 2024 #4
I am so happy they trust me! happybird May 2024 #5
It's UTTERLY WONDERful! elleng May 2024 #7
Boy that is a tough one the way that handrail winds through the bush. magicarpet May 2024 #8
Thank you! happybird May 2024 #12
Cat urban myth strikes again rockbluff botanist May 2024 #15
Found a cool video! happybird May 2024 #16
A super soaker water 'gun' has worked for us. Hope22 May 2024 #17

happybird

(5,113 posts)
3. I worry that would get on the birds' feet, too
Mon May 27, 2024, 08:13 PM
May 2024

They own that corner of the deck and I have seen them perched and hopping on that rail.

RockRaven

(16,251 posts)
9. Birds are generally much less sensitive to hot peppers than mammals
Mon May 27, 2024, 08:40 PM
May 2024

For example, there is a brand of seed cakes for suet-type feeders which are spiked with hot pepper to discourage squirrels, which we have used in the past. The birds love them, not bothered at all.

I don't know if sprinkling cayenne will solve the cat problem or not, but it shouldn't bother the birds much if you try it.

Donkees

(32,395 posts)
18. PLEASE don't use cayenne around birds, nestlings, and pollinators because you'll cause more harm
Tue May 28, 2024, 03:05 AM
May 2024

The Cornell Lab of Ornithology has advised against its use for some time now, including in bird food. Dusting an area with the powder does affect eyes and respiratory tracts.

Yes catbirds are very friendly and appreciate any care you show towards them.

happybird

(5,113 posts)
19. Thank you
Wed May 29, 2024, 08:14 PM
May 2024

Thought I responded the other night but must have fallen asleep. I was iffy on the cayenne so am glad you said something.

Since I can’t have a birdfeeder (bears), tomorrow I’m going to set out a few blueberries for them while I work in the yard and keep an eye out for the cat. Since I’ve never seen that cat in more than 4 years of living here, hopefully it was just passing through the area or skittish enough that being startled the other day will be enough to keep it away.

Donkees

(32,395 posts)
20. They are also fond of raisins, bite-sized chopped apple, seeded multigrain sliced bread pieces ...
Thu May 30, 2024, 02:23 AM
May 2024

and will let you know when their plate is empty I offer only small amounts at a time, in order not to attract squirrels.



-- EVER INSPIRED BY OUR SUMMERTIME CATBIRD FRIEND -
https://catbirdlife.com/

happybird

(5,113 posts)
6. I am a cat lover and enjoy visits from Willie, the black cat who lives down the road
Mon May 27, 2024, 08:30 PM
May 2024

He hangs out on the upper deck occasionally and I have enjoyed his sporadic company since my cat, Pooper, passed away a few months ago. She (and all the cats I’ve ever had) was indoor only.

This grey cat I had never seen before this evening.

dem4decades

(11,904 posts)
10. We feed birds, cats are killers, they kill song birds.
Mon May 27, 2024, 08:46 PM
May 2024

If someone owns a cat, they should keep it indoors. If a cat kills one of our hummers, well it better not.

happybird

(5,113 posts)
13. I agree
Mon May 27, 2024, 09:25 PM
May 2024

Not only for the birds, but because outdoor cats live violent lives and die painful deaths (no matter how sweet and docile they may be when spending time indoors). When I worked at the vet the thing we treated the most were painful abscesses outdoor cats got from fighting.

I'd love to have a birdfeeder or 5 but bears are a problem here. Wanted a beehive, too but no. Bears. Sigh.

dem4decades

(11,904 posts)
14. We have an occasional bear, we have plants that attract the hummers.
Mon May 27, 2024, 09:35 PM
May 2024

And our bird feeder is suspended 15 feet in the air. It's a pain in the butt to fill but if a bear comes by he's out of luck. There's coyotes around too, and a bobcat, why anyone would let a cat run outside is beyond me.

happybird

(5,113 posts)
5. I am so happy they trust me!
Mon May 27, 2024, 08:19 PM
May 2024

Over the past few weeks I think have have gotten used to me and my music. So grateful I was outside when the cat came. Their nest is high up in the shrub and burning bush is pretty bendy, so hoping it wouldn’t support the cat’s weight if it tries to climb in there.

magicarpet

(16,486 posts)
8. Boy that is a tough one the way that handrail winds through the bush.
Mon May 27, 2024, 08:39 PM
May 2024

You might try trimming the bottom of the bush so you can see in there. Then keep an eye on the bush for the cat hanging around.

Get a spray bottle and mix some cayenne pepper mixed in. Keep an eye out for the cat and spray its face with the spray bottle. Adjust the spray to a stream that way you get better distance and aim.

After you get the cat a few times with the spray it might get the hint and find someplace else to bird hunt. Be vigilant in case the cat is persistent as cats can be.

The cat knows the birds are nesting and hopes to catch the birds off guard. When the eggs hatch keep an extra eye out for them because little birds lack the defense skills of an adult bird so they are pretty much sitting ducks for the cat to prey on.

You might have to cover the handrail with a tarp and tie it on there to keep access to the bush to a minimum for the cat.

Keep us posted.

A bell collar on the cat might help alert the birds the cat is lurking around. But the owner might remove it. If it was your cat it might be worth a try.

How about little bells in the bush around the proximity of the nest ?

Out doors cats are the biggest danger and killers to nesting song birds.

happybird

(5,113 posts)
12. Thank you!
Mon May 27, 2024, 09:20 PM
May 2024

Usually I trim that bush back but haven't this year because of the birds. Will do that side tomorrow and try cayenne.

rockbluff botanist

(360 posts)
15. Cat urban myth strikes again
Mon May 27, 2024, 09:50 PM
May 2024

And, NO, cats are not the biggest killer of birds. That old myth really has staying power. It's been debunked many times over.

Cars, loss of habitat and pesticides are the big three killer of birds. Simply put, people are biggest threat to birds.

My husband and I are birders and avid bird photographers, heavily invested in expensive professional equipment. We have lots of birds and cats here on our farm. We plant only native shrubs and plants that attract and feed birds. That is the single best thing you can do for birds. And, of course donate to Audubon or Cornell Bird Lab.

Cats are going to get the occasional bird. But not near as many as predatory raptors like kites and hawks. Crows and many other birds attack nests too. They eat eggs and nestlings. Swallow tail kites are masters of this behavior. They patrol the tops of trees looking for nests. They are among the most beautiful of birds.

I have a motion sensitive sprinkler device that works very well on cats and most any animal. Look online.

happybird

(5,113 posts)
16. Found a cool video!
Mon May 27, 2024, 11:47 PM
May 2024

I know nothing about Catbirds, only yesterday managed to identify what kind of birds my little buddies are, and now trying to learn more about them. This video makes me feel less crazy! They are champion mimics! I’ve heard them making duck-like noises, the gentle “mrrrp mrrrp mrrrp” sound ducks make when swimming, not loud quacking. One of the neighbors has ducks. 😀

https://academy.allaboutbirds.org/an-expert-mimic-the-gray-catbird/

Hope22

(2,821 posts)
17. A super soaker water 'gun' has worked for us.
Tue May 28, 2024, 12:03 AM
May 2024

They shoot a stream of water but make quite a swoosh noise that cats do not like. It won’t hurt the cat but will discourage it from coming into that area.

Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Birders»One of my Catbird friends...