Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

ancianita

(42,668 posts)
7. Are you saying the fake pro-lifers are the hospitals themselves? or the religion that established them? Because the
Wed Nov 19, 2025, 06:26 AM
Nov 19

headlines of your links don't say that.

In both examples fake pro-lifers are the individuals who made the wrong decisions about the pregnant women -- not the org or religion they belong to. Reread the report. The very fact that

In a statement, Franciscan Health Crown Point President and CEO Raymond Grady told ABC News that the hospital is investigating the incident
means that they are trying to understand the "mistake" of the individual nurse. But your headline provokes a distorted implication about Catholics.

In the second example, some individual in that hospital decided on the pregnant woman's discharge instead of weighing her risks over the hospital's costs.

What those individuals decided that hurt those women was likely influenced by Indiana's or the hospital's culture. Those individuals prioritized the culture over their hospital's guidance. But they might not have if they'd known what would happen with those women afterward. But it's still on them. Possibly the hospitals are liable for those individuals' decisions, too. It's not clear in the report where the buck stopped.

Recommendations

7 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

I suspected something so I looked the mother up SamuelTheThird Nov 19 #1
"the hospital is investigating the incident." Prof. Toru Tanaka Nov 19 #2
A Great Big YEAH, YEAH,YEAH! jaymac Nov 19 #6
I see big money on the horizon Puppyjive Nov 19 #3
Victims have lawyers, this hospital will pay BlueWaveNeverEnd Nov 19 #4
This makes zero sense..l Bread and Circuses Nov 19 #5
Are you saying the fake pro-lifers are the hospitals themselves? or the religion that established them? Because the ancianita Nov 19 #7
Anti-Catholic bigotry still exists in this country SocialDemocrat61 Nov 19 #8
The problem is when it comes to healthcare The Revolution Nov 19 #14
Thanks for proving my point! SocialDemocrat61 Nov 19 #15
It's not bigotry to be opposed to an organization The Revolution Nov 19 #16
Thanks again SocialDemocrat61 Nov 19 #17
How childish The Revolution Nov 19 #19
Have a nice day SocialDemocrat61 Nov 19 #20
I'm a Catholic BeerBarrelPolka Nov 19 #21
Yes there are good Catholics SocialDemocrat61 Nov 19 #22
Of course it's bigotry BeerBarrelPolka Nov 19 #23
Sorry to hear about your illness SocialDemocrat61 Nov 19 #24
Thank you BeerBarrelPolka Nov 19 #25
I take issue with your last statement Jilly_in_VA Nov 19 #26
The Evangelicals literally loathe the Catholics BeerBarrelPolka Nov 19 #28
Which has nothing to do with your statement. Jilly_in_VA Nov 19 #29
What are you talking about? BeerBarrelPolka Nov 19 #30
That's exactly my point The Revolution Nov 19 #31
1. According to recent data, about 15.8% of all short-term acute care hospitals are Catholic-owned or affiliated. ancianita Nov 19 #33
The article I provided answes a lot of this The Revolution Thursday #39
I make a distinction between individuals who are Catholic, Crunchy Frog Nov 19 #36
Glad you do SocialDemocrat61 Thursday #41
With good reason; you paint a half picture. Conjuay Saturday #44
No Right wing people are ruining the country. SocialDemocrat61 Saturday #45
i'm referring to anti birth control, anti abortion religious hospitals. Catholic or otherwise. FAKE PRO LIFERS BlueWaveNeverEnd Nov 19 #10
You posted an article without using it to support the header claim. Is there anything in the article that ancianita Nov 19 #34
How does a single individual nurse Crunchy Frog Nov 19 #35
I know nothing about this hospital and whether or not it has a full obstetrics unit, but increasingly... hlthe2b Nov 19 #9
they shd b transferred to said nearby hospital. mopinko Nov 19 #12
Most hospitals TRY to do so, but if it is imminently emergent or the patient/parents refuse, they cannot force hlthe2b Nov 19 #13
Reddit comment: As a POC I never in my life felt more uncomfortable than when I visited Indiana. Never again . Swede Nov 19 #11
2000+ years ago, a religion could be spun from this incident. RedWhiteBlueIsRacist Nov 19 #18
WWJD? Jilly_in_VA Nov 19 #27
Upthread comment: Catholic hospitals are the only option in many areas. GJGCA Nov 19 #32
LAWSUIT Jack Valentino Nov 19 #37
Sue the hospital. No woman should have to beg. She could have died !!!!! By Trueblue1968 Nov 19 #38
They just made that baby RICH. Maru Kitteh Thursday #40
Update!! Doctor nurse fired BlueWaveNeverEnd Saturday #42
Mercy Hospital in the 1970s Blue Full Moon Saturday #43
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»UPDATE!! Catholic Hospit...»Reply #7