Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

John1956PA

(4,839 posts)
36. You have described the situation very well.
Sat Jan 10, 2026, 08:12 PM
22 hrs ago

As an aside, I will suggest that it may not even have been a situation of civil disobedience. I do not know what events led up to her car being parked sideways blocking one lane of travel or how long it had been there. Maybe she turned to travel up the street, saw some action, started making a "K" turn, and then paused to record the action. I do not know if the eventual shooter ordered her to leave. All we know so far about their conversation was that she stated she was not "mad" at him. Maybe he told her to stay where she was so that he could walk around her car to video record it. We will have to wait until further facts are known.

Recommendations

5 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

She was murdered in cold blood. Not arrested and given her day in court. Irish_Dem 22 hrs ago #1
If Good was not named in a juducual warrant, then ICE has no power of arrest Bluetus 6 hrs ago #119
So they had to kill her because they couldn't arrest her. Irish_Dem 6 hrs ago #122
Well, in the mind of the shooter, I guess that's about right. Bluetus 3 hrs ago #132
He was clearly furious with her. Because he couldn't terrorize her or arrest her. Irish_Dem 3 hrs ago #133
He has a history of violence behind the badge Bluetus 2 hrs ago #134
No attempt to run over yankee87 22 hrs ago #2
I agree... that was an act of rage, not self defense. mikelewis 22 hrs ago #10
Rage? Cirsium 22 hrs ago #39
Sadly, when you got the president coming out saying you're a hero for stone cold murder... mikelewis 22 hrs ago #18
Maybe just me, but your link is suspicious. NH Ethylene 22 hrs ago #3
It's Channel 5 news in Mn... mikelewis 22 hrs ago #6
My computer decided it was malicious and blocked it. NH Ethylene 22 hrs ago #11
"She was actually interfering with law enforcement and could have been arrested. Sorry, that's the reality." sop 22 hrs ago #4
I've no idea... the charge I would have slapped on her would have been impeding law enforcement... mikelewis 22 hrs ago #9
Huh? Cirsium 22 hrs ago #16
Impeding what laws from being enforced? sop 22 hrs ago #25
You mean have the police write her a ticket NJCher 4 hrs ago #128
It's legal to protest, what she did might warrant a traffic citation questionseverything 21 hrs ago #58
And who are you? choie 21 hrs ago #66
" interfering with law enforcement" Conjuay 13 min ago #136
Worst take I've seen. johnp3907 22 hrs ago #5
But, but, but Cirsium 22 hrs ago #12
there were fucking cars going around her vehicle right before the agents approached her car bigtree 22 hrs ago #7
Bullshit Cirsium 22 hrs ago #8
You are so right... somehow I'm in league with Trump wanting to murder citizens.... mikelewis 22 hrs ago #13
I hit a nerve I guess Cirsium 22 hrs ago #19
maybe take your own advice? eShirl 7 hrs ago #113
No, YOU grow up Mike, and stop trying to couch your opinion LuckyCharms 5 hrs ago #123
Message auto-removed Name removed 25 min ago #135
You certainly make a lot of unsupported assertions Torchlight 22 hrs ago #14
Your tone is callous and disgusting Prairie Gates 22 hrs ago #15
This post is bullshit Republican talking points. It has been sent to the jury as objectionable. flashman13 22 hrs ago #17
How on earth is this a Repbulican Talking point... do you not understand words? mikelewis 22 hrs ago #22
How on earth could anyone think you are victim blaming??? dpibel 22 hrs ago #35
Post removed Post removed 22 hrs ago #38
Hard to believe dpibel 22 hrs ago #44
Yeah, that was heartbreaking 💔 and Cha 21 hrs ago #61
What does that even mean? MorbidButterflyTat 18 hrs ago #93
It was Crude, Vulgar, and Insulting to Cha 17 hrs ago #97
yeah, that was offensive NJCher 4 hrs ago #129
I expect that you're right. Orrex 22 hrs ago #49
Wasn't she also an observer witness? GreenWave 22 hrs ago #20
No law enforcement was happening, she was trying to follow orders, and any of the things you describe in your OP WhiskeyGrinder 22 hrs ago #21
She was blocking traffic and laying on the horn... mikelewis 22 hrs ago #23
"This proves she was murdered by ICE." What does? Ross being frustrated? Plenty of jurors would find that justifiable. WhiskeyGrinder 22 hrs ago #37
Like it's ever going to a jury... no, I wanted to know... mikelewis 22 hrs ago #42
This video canetoad 22 hrs ago #45
It's hard to tell at least on a phone (mine) vs a ? tablet or especially a computer, but the horn sound was not.... electric_blue68 20 hrs ago #71
Why the hell is the OP here so sure the horn was coming from her car? Wiz Imp 20 hrs ago #80
Bullshit. She was NOT blocking traffic. Wiz Imp 20 hrs ago #79
That's a bit aggressive canetoad 19 hrs ago #86
Not directed at you Cirsium 6 hrs ago #118
SHE WAS NOT "BLOCKING TRAFFIC" Cosmocat 9 hrs ago #110
you DON'T KNOW THE REALITY. Cha 22 hrs ago #24
You are correct... all I have is video angles... Are you saying they didn't murder her? They clearly did! mikelewis 22 hrs ago #28
Sorry, but I served 30 years as a Federal LEO.. Wuddles440 22 hrs ago #26
Correct and they had no jurisdiction whatsoever to serve a traffic stop. mikelewis 22 hrs ago #31
Renee was not the "antagonizer" in the killer's eyes. valleyrogue 21 hrs ago #67
So what? Picaro 22 hrs ago #27
But I thought canetoad 22 hrs ago #47
Sure as hell wouldn't want you on any juries bluestarone 22 hrs ago #29
Well this video proves he stone cold killed her... so you might. mikelewis 22 hrs ago #34
What are your motives? MorbidButterflyTat 17 hrs ago #94
Sure, she was engaging in peaceful civil disobedience EarlG 22 hrs ago #30
I agree... but I think this video proves the ICE agent acted out of anger... not duty. mikelewis 22 hrs ago #33
I think they're pissed off because you said that she was interfering with law enforcement EarlG 22 hrs ago #46
TY.. That was cruel.. ".. she showed her ass.. " Cha 22 hrs ago #53
Not of Duty, not of Anger. But of Malice. LuvLoogie 19 hrs ago #85
That's not true Cirsium 6 hrs ago #121
read up on attribution theory NJCher 4 hrs ago #130
You have described the situation very well. John1956PA 22 hrs ago #36
thank you Skittles 21 hrs ago #70
She had Missouri plates on her car. MichMan 20 hrs ago #83
They'd never find her! dpibel 19 hrs ago #87
Not sure I follow EarlG 19 hrs ago #90
There were posts stating the police could just go to her house and arrest her since they had her plate number MichMan 18 hrs ago #91
Missouri markie 11 hrs ago #101
You must have just moved there in the last 60 days MichMan 9 hrs ago #107
It used to be... Mike Nelson 22 hrs ago #32
Shooter had her license plate on his phone. moondust 22 hrs ago #40
Correct... she lived on the street. Any real police would have just tacked on another charge... mikelewis 22 hrs ago #43
Has ICE in the current crackdown ever "followed up" with an impeding arrest? Prairie Gates 22 hrs ago #56
She was not a suspect and she would not be evading arrest MorbidButterflyTat 17 hrs ago #95
Whatever R0ckyRac00n 22 hrs ago #41
They fucking terrorized her... LuckyCharms 22 hrs ago #48
ICE had no legal authority to tell a US citizen to get out of the vehicle and they are also not traffic cops lostnfound 22 hrs ago #50
She moved when they finally pulled up towards her underpants 22 hrs ago #51
Nope UpInArms 22 hrs ago #52
hmmmm Kali 22 hrs ago #54
Just sharing an observation from an old man here .... anciano 22 hrs ago #55
good observation markie 11 hrs ago #102
Which doesn't justify her murder. mzmolly 21 hrs ago #57
How do you justify saying "blocking the street" dpibel 21 hrs ago #59
Wow, just wow !!! MarineCombatEngineer 21 hrs ago #60
the whitewashers are everywhere Skittles 21 hrs ago #69
According to local redditors, KSTP leans right AStern 21 hrs ago #62
Who cares? They're still not allowed to shoot/kill people. tinrobot 21 hrs ago #63
No MikeLewis - she was not impeding them. NoMoreRepugs 21 hrs ago #64
I took another look. mzmolly 21 hrs ago #65
Find myself wondering: how many people who say she was blocking traffic have ever driven on icy roads Attilatheblond 19 hrs ago #88
It was at most a matter of a traffic infraction for having her moniss 21 hrs ago #68
ICE is not "law enforcement" Bluetus 20 hrs ago #72
This leftstreet 20 hrs ago #77
Jeeze she was blocking one lane!!! Door dash drivers do it all the time!!! Eko 20 hrs ago #73
What is this "clearly showing her ass" bullshit? LuckyCharms 20 hrs ago #74
+1 leftstreet 20 hrs ago #75
THANK YOU! nt Cha 20 hrs ago #81
Who talks like that? MorbidButterflyTat 17 hrs ago #96
He was also speculating about what charge he would "slap on her" Prairie Gates 4 hrs ago #124
Exercising free speech rights is "clearly showing her ass" ??! Jack Valentino 20 hrs ago #76
Welcome to DU. nilram 20 hrs ago #78
How come none of the other videos featured honking like this? nt pnwmom 20 hrs ago #82
This message was self-deleted by its author MichMan 20 hrs ago #84
The drift of this op is... orangecrush 19 hrs ago #89
"Sorry, that's the reality." MorbidButterflyTat 18 hrs ago #92
LOL NJCher 4 hrs ago #131
Your 'real' law enforcement have murdered protestors as well SamuelTheThird 17 hrs ago #98
A bit of cultural appropriation Keepthesoulalive 15 hrs ago #99
Perhaps the OP should have said tavernier 12 hrs ago #100
;-{) ICE COLD KILLERS Goonch 11 hrs ago #103
All this discussion of the various charges Good might have faced... BH liberal 11 hrs ago #104
This thread is victim blaming and should have been alerted on. gab13by13 11 hrs ago #105
Agreed. One of the OP's ugly in-thread replies was hidden Orrex 10 hrs ago #106
Maybe it was MichMan 9 hrs ago #108
I did obamanut2012 7 hrs ago #117
I alerted and it was allowed to stand obamanut2012 7 hrs ago #116
I do not agree with your assessment at all Cosmocat 9 hrs ago #109
Even in this, your most charitable interpretation, her crime was to blow her horn and whistle. Scrivener7 8 hrs ago #111
designated a terrorist for blowing a fucking whistle eShirl 7 hrs ago #112
This OP should be posted in Freeperville Jersey Devil 7 hrs ago #114
OP can't respond. Locked out of the thread Kaleva 7 hrs ago #115
There's a sort of cosmic justice to the fact that the post stood Prairie Gates 4 hrs ago #125
Nope Solly Mack 6 hrs ago #120
She was fleeing being assaulted and kidnapped. aeromanKC 4 hrs ago #126
Would love to read your take on Rules of Engagement Aviation Pro 4 hrs ago #127
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»New angle shows Good bloc...»Reply #36