Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

yardwork

(69,535 posts)
8. This sounds reasonable but doesn't hold up as an argument.
Wed May 6, 2026, 12:35 PM
12 hrs ago

After 9/11, most Americans, from the president down, rightly pointed out the difference between the people who engineered the attack and everybody else who happens to be Muslim. The only ones implying that it was understandable that Muslim individuals might be blamed for what a few of them (or as we've now learned, the leadership of Saudi Arabia) did were right wing cretins.

Similarly, Trump and others who identify (loudly) as Christians are doing horrible things, but anybody suggesting that this means that all Christians are at risk for being blamed would be ridiculed.

Yet when the issue is Israel there's a collective shrug about terrorist attacks on Jewish people, at best. At worst we read that they deserve it because reasons.

I don't want to be blamed for the horrible things white Christians are doing.

Recommendations

6 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Thank you for posting this. murielm99 16 hrs ago #1
I agree it is not the fault of Jewish Americans but then again, where is the outrage, where is the condemnation of the ratchiweenie 14 hrs ago #5
Why do American Jews carry that responsibility? Happy Hoosier 12 hrs ago #10
In fact, one could reasonably assume that a Jewish person living in the U.S. disagrees with Israel. yardwork 11 hrs ago #11
Why? Because to some, we aren't real Americans and never will be. Behind the Aegis 1 hr ago #25
This is, objectively, bullshit. yardwork 10 hrs ago #13
Why are the world's Jews required to express outrage? DavidDvorkin 10 hrs ago #17
" But then again...". Does that mean there is an excuse for any reason to Assault Jewish Americans? Melon 10 hrs ago #18
Will this fade quickly on DU? DavidDvorkin 15 hrs ago #2
Most every story fades quickly on DU. maxsolomon 13 hrs ago #6
Seems to be a world wide trend. Given the increasingly negative view of Israel & its actions, only likely to get worse dutch777 15 hrs ago #3
This sounds reasonable but doesn't hold up as an argument. yardwork 12 hrs ago #8
There Muslims and Christians that support JI7 10 hrs ago #12
Exactly. There's no justification, period. yardwork 10 hrs ago #14
A few things: no_hypocrisy 15 hrs ago #4
What was going on in 1980? maxsolomon 13 hrs ago #7
Interesting. I think that was the year I was threatened because I was a "Christ Killer". Behind the Aegis 10 hrs ago #20
Crimony where was this? maxsolomon 10 hrs ago #21
It was outside Atlanta. Behind the Aegis 9 hrs ago #23
These are dark days and looking darker in many ways Torchlight 12 hrs ago #9
K&R Solly Mack 10 hrs ago #15
We reap what we sow. republianmushroom 10 hrs ago #16
Why would someone Jewish say this? Behind the Aegis 10 hrs ago #19
Sowing prejudice DaBronx 38 min ago #26
This isn't okay MustLoveBeagles 9 hrs ago #22
K&R betsuni 9 hrs ago #24
For the "There's no antisemitism on the Left!" brigade Sympthsical 15 min ago #27
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Assaults on Jews Reach 46...»Reply #8