Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Sympthsical

(11,082 posts)
40. But alarmism isn't helpful
Fri May 8, 2026, 03:43 AM
21 hrs ago

Emotions guiding response is the antithesis of evidence-based logic that should reign in science and medicine. Speculation and extrapolation work against these principles.

From the WHO:

Dr. Maria Van Kerkhove, Director, Epidemic and Pandemic Management, clarified, "This is not covid, nor influenza, it spreads very differently . . . We currently have no symptomatic passengers or crew onboard. In past outbreaks of Andes virus, human-to-human transmission primarily occurred among close contacts," she added.

Dr. Abdirahman Mahamud, Director at the Alert and Response Coordination Department of the WHO's Emergencies Health Programme, said, "We had a similar situation in Argentina in 2018 - 2019, where a symptomatic individual attended a social gathering that led to a lot of people getting infected. We are in a similar situation right now, with a cluster in a confined space and close contact. If we follow public health measures, with contact tracing and isolation, we can break this chain of transmission. It doesn't need to be a large epidemic. It has happened in a specific confined setting where people are interacting in a prolonged close contact," added. Dr. Mahamud.

"It is similar to the Agrentia outbreak, and we don't anticipate a large epidemic. With public health measures, we can break the chain of transmission, and this will be a limited outbreak."

Dr. Van Kerkhove also stressed, "This is not coronavirus. This is a very different virus that has existed for quite some time. This is not the beginning of a Covid pandemic; this is an outbreak we are observing on the ship, occurring in a confined area."


Emphases mine. There are enough things in the world we genuinely need to worry about. Setting one more log on the pyre when people are already walking mental health disasters feels flippant and cruel. People don't need to be freaked out any more than they already are.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Let the Games Begin! ZDU Wednesday #1
God help us orangecrush Wednesday #2
Last night my Maine Coon cat woke me up by laying on his back beside my bed & tossing a dead mouse from paw to paw. FSogol Wednesday #3
Good Kitty! orangecrush Wednesday #4
My dogs caught a gopher two nights ago -then one buried it womanofthehills Wednesday #12
Yuck! We have to lock out cat door. Our house would be full of raccoons and possums. n/t FSogol Wednesday #14
I'm not getting on any cruise ships & I have 2 cats irisblue Wednesday #5
Good luck! orangecrush Wednesday #6
It is most likely edhopper Thursday #22
I Thought It Was Spread By Rodents ProfessorGAC Wednesday #7
Check this out orangecrush Wednesday #8
Son Of A Gun! ProfessorGAC Wednesday #9
Not at all. orangecrush Wednesday #10
So it was brought on the ship edhopper Thursday #23
Thanks, here we go again. appalachiablue Thursday #27
You betcha! orangecrush Thursday #31
This particular Hantavirus John Farmer Thursday #35
Yeah, I Saw That After I First Posted ProfessorGAC Thursday #37
Ten yrs ago, a young college girl a town over in NM died of Hanta virus womanofthehills Wednesday #11
Very sad orangecrush Wednesday #15
Not necessarily hantavirus. Arthur_Frain Wednesday #13
That's how Gene Hackman's wife died. He died from other causes. LeftInTX Wednesday #16
Check this out orangecrush Thursday #19
Yes, but this hantavirus is also endemic to Argentina. LeftInTX Thursday #21
Thanks orangecrush Thursday #32
There are different strains of it. LisaL 20 hrs ago #41
No cruise ships for me, I can't believe they had it happen on the cruise ship MV Hondius Beringia Wednesday #17
Who the hell takes a 35 day cruise? Initech Wednesday #18
I can't even afford a 3 hour tour! orangecrush Thursday #20
I'm pretty sure it's one of those eco-cruises. Ship only has capacity for 196 people. LeftInTX Thursday #25
Thanks orangecrush Thursday #29
So it was brought on board edhopper Thursday #24
East to answer Traildogbob Thursday #26
Not nearly as transmissable as Covid Sympthsical Thursday #28
I seem to remember hearing something similar orangecrush Thursday #30
Because cruises are human sardine cans Sympthsical Thursday #33
Human sardine cans orangecrush Thursday #38
But alarmism isn't helpful Sympthsical 21 hrs ago #40
Not as easy to transmit and not transmissible aren't the same EdmondDantes_ Thursday #34
It all depends on how communicable it is human to human. In any case, in this country we'd know where Vinca Thursday #36
I have a feeling orangecrush Thursday #39
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Are we sitting ducks for ...»Reply #40