General Discussion

AloeVera

(4,652 posts)

36. Logic?

Fri Jun 26, 2026, 09:16 PM

16 hrs ago

Can't blame Jews for the actions of Israel because Jews are not responsible for what Israel does. To do so is anti-semitism (TRUE!)

Can't criticize Israel because then you are blaming Jews (HUH?? Now Jews ARE responsible? FALSE!)

Netanyahu claimed that he represents all Jewish people in the world. This conflation, combined with his genocidal actions, make him the biggest driver of anti-semitism in the world. Maybe he's the biggest anti-semite just for how he is harming Jews!

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

8 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Eko Ponietz Celerity Grey5 Bettie Hey Joe susanr516 mr715

96 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Hundreds of rabbis accuse Mamdani of fueling antisemitism over 'monsters' comment [View all] question everything Yesterday OP

So, is AIPAC scared, or angry? Fiendish Thingy 23 hrs ago #1

Both. mountain grammy 23 hrs ago #2

Yes mr715 21 hrs ago #9

whatever.... mike_c 23 hrs ago #3

Blaming Jewish or Israeli people for the Eko 22 hrs ago #4

he was criticizing AIPAC and it's dark money PACs hookaleft 22 hrs ago #7

Logic? AloeVera 16 hrs ago #36

Thanks AloeVera! Eko 16 hrs ago #38

And speaking of logic... AloeVera 16 hrs ago #39

Fuck this racist claptrap Sympthsical 14 hrs ago #55

"Say no to AIPAC" is not aimed at just Jews, it's aimed at everyone muriel_volestrangler 4 hrs ago #72

Stop. Sympthsical 4 hrs ago #74

Stop what? muriel_volestrangler 3 hrs ago #77

Stop running interference for these antisemitic tropes Sympthsical 3 hrs ago #79

I really do not see people blaming Jews on DU muriel_volestrangler 2 hrs ago #83

And your thoughts on Sympthsical 1 hr ago #87

People should not say "If the Jews would just do X, then people wouldn't hate them!" muriel_volestrangler 1 hr ago #91

It's literally the post I replied to Sympthsical 59 min ago #92

No, it's not. The post you replied to says muriel_volestrangler 41 min ago #94

Wow Sympthsical 7 min ago #95

Everything he said was true. hookaleft 22 hrs ago #5

Who is "they?" Mossfern 13 hrs ago #57

Netanyahu should be attacked lame54 22 hrs ago #6

LMAO fuck you, AIPAC n/t aocommunalpunch 21 hrs ago #8

The popular new brand of lipstick. Behind the Aegis 21 hrs ago #10

So, for you, the problem is not the ideology of AIPAC. It's just that it's not 100% successful. Intractable 21 hrs ago #12

Strawman much? Behind the Aegis 20 hrs ago #13

Oh, how is it not the case? I see no argument here. Just a vacuous statement. Intractable 20 hrs ago #14

Lipstick on a pig Behind the Aegis 20 hrs ago #15

Post removed Post removed 20 hrs ago #18

You are accusing a DUer of lying? yardwork 1 hr ago #86

Your supposed "truth" is irrelevant and is a feeble distraction from the main point. Intractable 20 hrs ago #19

BtA doesn't "lie" and it's not "feeble Or irrelevant. Cha 15 hrs ago #46

You keep pointing at who is funding it when many people other than Jewish people fund it also. Eko 18 hrs ago #25

According to Protocols... sarisataka 19 hrs ago #23

Rothchild, Soros, Zionist, AIPAC ... lapucelle 17 hrs ago #29

I think you misunderstood this poster. yardwork 14 hrs ago #51

I've been reading his posts for years now. There's no misunderstanding from either of us. Intractable 14 hrs ago #52

Here Is All the Money AIPAC Spent on the 2024 Elections hookaleft 20 hrs ago #17

There may be some apples and oranges mixed in here, but..... DFW 6 hrs ago #68

Mahalo, BtA.. It's no big mystery why Cha 15 hrs ago #44

Thank you! Bookmarking. betsuni 13 hrs ago #62

Sometime, probably soon. The rabbis will learn the US ain't taking it so much anymore. 31j20b3 21 hrs ago #11

82% of NY jews... Boo1 20 hrs ago #21

Wisconsin has many fewer Jewish identifiers 31j20b3 20 hrs ago #22

I dont agree that anti-zionism is antisemitic. Eko 18 hrs ago #26

Including Palestinians? Boo1 17 hrs ago #32

Here. Eko 16 hrs ago #37

What's the difference in having a right Boo1 15 hrs ago #41

inherent Eko 15 hrs ago #48

That goes for Muslim countries too? Mossfern 13 hrs ago #58

Yes Eko 12 hrs ago #63

So you support a One World government? Mossfern 4 hrs ago #73

Nowhere did I say that. Eko 1 hr ago #89

Is it possible Eko 11 hrs ago #65

Sure Mossfern 4 hrs ago #69

It is not merely the belief that Jewish people have a homeland Eko 1 hr ago #88

Palestine was not a nation Mossfern 1 hr ago #90

I think so. Joinfortmill 3 hrs ago #78

Just a correction here... Violet_Crumble 8 hrs ago #67

I am well aware of the expulsion of Palestinians as well as their leaving voluntarily during the 1948 war. Mossfern 4 hrs ago #71

US Gentiles have no problem with the Jewish population. In fact we love and welcome you to the Democratic Party hookaleft 17 hrs ago #33

Are the palestinians Boo1 17 hrs ago #34

Post removed Post removed 17 hrs ago #35

If the Palestinians didn't want Hamas Boo1 15 hrs ago #40

Well, if someone could move into your home at any time Bettie 2 hrs ago #81

Rabbis in the US are "Sowing" the actions of Israel sarisataka 18 hrs ago #24

Mamdani accused AIPAC of pouring "millions of dark-money dollars" into efforts to turn the public against itself. Nanjeanne 20 hrs ago #16

+1 leftstreet 15 hrs ago #43

Exact quotes. LAS14 20 hrs ago #20

This is the most complete transcript of his speech I can find muriel_volestrangler 3 hrs ago #75

What fuels antisemitism is people like them conflating Jews and Israel/AIPAC RockRaven 17 hrs ago #27

Couldn't agree more and said so in Post # 36. nt AloeVera 15 hrs ago #42

"Jews are to blame for antisemitism." Boo1 15 hrs ago #45

Netanyahu is a monster. AloeVera 15 hrs ago #47

Netanyahu and the actions of his government Eko 14 hrs ago #49

+1 dalton99a 4 hrs ago #70

This message was self-deleted by its author Ponietz 2 hrs ago #80

I'm not Jewish, but I have Jewish relatives... Joinfortmill 17 hrs ago #28

There are elections planned later this year question everything 17 hrs ago #30

AIPAC goal is throwing money at centrists. Emile 17 hrs ago #31

not just centrist and conservative Dems but also hard RWer MAGAt rethugs, including 2020 seditionists and traitors Celerity 13 hrs ago #59

And what do the Catholic priests say? Iggo 14 hrs ago #50

Bibi makes the propaganda run on time Ponietz 14 hrs ago #53

So it's only OK to call Muslims monsters? CivicGrief 14 hrs ago #54

Ii haven't heard anyone here say anything of the sort. Mossfern 13 hrs ago #61

Just (One Person) Wondering... wyn borkins 13 hrs ago #56

The I/P forum tries hard to host these kinds of discussions, but in reality the independent forums hlthe2b 21 sec ago #96

There will be no peace until a fair 2 multigraincracker 13 hrs ago #60

My take for what it is worth. sheshe2 11 hrs ago #64

I was surprised this happened. I hope he learns, too. betsuni 10 hrs ago #66

Not a very smart statement on his part. MineralMan 3 hrs ago #76

Religion is the most divisive thing Bettie 2 hrs ago #82

100% Agree! MineralMan 2 hrs ago #84

My husband and I talk sometimes about Bettie 2 hrs ago #85

Congratulations on your 20,000 post milestone. Now on to your next niyad 46 min ago #93