Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

EndlessWire

(8,039 posts)
13. Judge has a point
Fri Jun 20, 2025, 09:32 AM
Jun 20

If he dismisses the case, all rump can do is appeal, which he'll do one way or another. Her motion is an immunity defense?

This case is important to us all, as handcuffing a judge and doing a perp walk from her courtroom is an invasion of the judicial system which rump is trying to control. We can't let him do that.

It is unique in that the Judge that will grant or deny her motion is himself a judge with some idea of his own immunity, too. There's nowhere Dugan can go where she would not be judged by another of her peers. I guess the RW SC can look forward to twisting the law again.

I dunno. Put me on the jury. I think that she was in command of her courtroom, in command of the immigrant guy, and had a right to tell him which door to go out. She had a right to do that, especially if the paperwork was not in order. It's not her fault that ICE was incompetent, but it's her job to know--at the very least, she had a right to maintain order in her own courtroom.

Kudos to this Judge who had the guts to tell ICE they didn't have it together.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

The goal is to torture and humiliate Dem leaders, judges, etc. Irish_Dem Jun 20 #1
Yep. OldBaldy1701E Jun 20 #3
The judge handling the case is a Clinton appointee. onenote Jun 20 #7
Even more shameful. Irish_Dem Jun 20 #11
Sounds to me like she didn't want to set a trial date because she thinks the judge's motion to dismiss might win. SunSeeker Jun 20 #16
For the majority of people, judges are not humiliated, but rather grow in stature. Magoo48 Jun 20 #8
If only... 2naSalit Jun 20 #2
Case is done right... atreides1 Jun 20 #4
And unnecessarily drive the defendant's legal bills through the roof. rubbersole Jun 20 #9
Rushing to trial without waiting for the outcome of the motion to dismiss would drive bills up. onenote Jun 20 #17
"I call balls and strikes" wolfie001 Jun 20 #5
What happened JustAnotherGen Jun 20 #6
Under the speedy trial act, the date for the trial would not be until August, or later onenote Jun 20 #18
Sounds to me, like the judge over her case has been intimidated 70sEraVet Jun 20 #10
What happened to the right to a speedy trial? mzmolly Jun 20 #12
See post #18 onenote Jun 20 #19
Judge has a point EndlessWire Jun 20 #13
So the judge has had the motion to dismiss in front of him for the last 30 days moniss Jun 20 #14
Timeline of the case to date onenote Jun 20 #20
Thank you -- this is a legitimately helpful post. Mike Niendorff Jun 21 #21
"helping immigrant evade ICE" - Kid Rock's restaurant did the same by shutting down temporarily. Norrrm Jun 20 #15
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Judge accused of helping ...»Reply #13