Latest Breaking News

Prairie Gates

(5,878 posts)

12. LOL: How do you know?

Fri Jun 27, 2025, 12:19 PM

Jun 27

Well, you see, centrifuges are very sensitive and require a lot of calibration.

OK, and? What's your evidence?

So, these bombs caused a lot of vibrations just based on their size and the satellite imagery.

OK, and?

If the centrifuges are sensitive to vibration, and the bombs caused a lot of vibration, then the centrifuges are no longer operational. QED.

OK, buddy.

This is all very nice deductive reasoning - it's all very Aristotelian, in fact. But what it means is they have no actual observations or information about the centrifuges at all, much less empirical evidence that they were knocked out of commission by these bombings.

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Owl

13 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

IAEA chief: Fordow centrifuges 'no longer operational' after US bunker-buster strikes [View all] Richard D Jun 26 OP

unless they were moved? Kali Jun 26 #1

I'm far from an expert . . . Richard D Jun 26 #3

Yes Kali Jun 26 #4

No one claims there was no damage. The question isn't whether the centrifuges are currently operational... thesquanderer Jun 26 #2

"A Global Inventory of Organized Social Media Manipulation" - Oxford University Press ForgoTheConsequence Jun 26 #5

Please find . . . Richard D Jun 26 #6

Weird. ForgoTheConsequence Jun 27 #11

Media Bias Fact Check Beastly Boy Jun 26 #7

There are many other sources as well. Richard D Jun 26 #8

This story from the UK Telegraph seems to be a good compilation of Deminpenn Jun 27 #9

centrifuges are usually detected via heat signature, because they require a lot of concentrated power. Javaman Jun 27 #10

LOL: How do you know? Prairie Gates Jun 27 #12

A rather huge disparity between 'no longer functional' and 'obliterates' Torchlight Jun 27 #13