Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

Cirsium

(3,711 posts)
29. I know
Fri Jan 30, 2026, 07:31 PM
Jan 30

It is ridiculous. Are people unable to think in terms other than the the punishment model for every social ill?

Immigrants are escaping much worse exploitation on the other side of the border. Workers on the farms here are paid the same no matter their status, and that is not at all unusual. The children of immigrants here are getting college educations and buying homes. Punishing farmers closes that window of opportunity. I don't know of any farmer intentionally hiring "illegals." Of course, there are always exceptions.

If you want someone to blame, go after the capitalists from the US and Europe who are running the sweat shops, mines and plantations in the global south and supporting police state regimes. Go after management everywhere for widespread systemic worker exploitation and advocate for organized labor if you want a comprehensive and humane "solution" to the so-called "problem" of immigration.

The problem is not immigration, it is neo-colonialism, which is driving millions of people into desperation.

Recommendations

0 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

George W Bush, to his credit, provided a blueprint. RandySF Jan 30 #1
ICE definitely doesn't obey the law. C Moon Jan 30 #2
THAT IS THE OVERWHELMING MAJORITY OF THEM, ASSHOLE Skittles Jan 30 #3
Someone spike his milk? No one wants to "solve" immigration. DJ Synikus Makisimus Jan 30 #4
Yup. If they wanted to solve undocumented worker problem it could easily and efficiently be done travelingthrulife Jan 30 #18
Fuck Newt! BidenRocks Jan 30 #5
Oh absolutely PatSeg Jan 30 #20
Thank you Cirsium Jan 30 #24
From the man who helped write the book on GOP dirty tactics, revenge, evil. Irish_Dem Jan 30 #6
Green card greymattermom Jan 30 #7
And they are locking them up too Historic NY Jan 30 #22
You started alot of the shit that got us to where we are at as a nation, Newt! Chasstev365 Jan 30 #8
STFU, sNewty! 2naSalit Jan 30 #9
I seem to recall there was a bipartisan bill to address this that TSF torpedoed. sinkingfeeling Jan 30 #10
and what exactly does this piece of shit know about obeying the law. Javaman Jan 30 #11
Maybe Newty's Having A Lee Atwater Moment, IYKWIM.🤞 ColoringFool Jan 30 #12
Time for Gingrich to shut his cancerous mouth. Old Crank Jan 30 #13
B!!eware damifino10 Jan 30 #14
Newty said in Feb 2025 Trump may be the most consequential president since Lincoln Raven123 Jan 30 #15
Who reanimated this fossil And asked for his opinion? Ray Bruns Jan 30 #16
Isn't he dead yet?? travelingthrulife Jan 30 #17
Ask the companies that employ them in order to exploit them for cheap labor, valleyrogue Jan 30 #19
What's wrong with that? Cirsium Jan 30 #25
My point is this: These people are blaming the people who come here and NOT the employers valleyrogue Jan 30 #28
I know Cirsium Jan 30 #29
People really need to go and investigate their own families backgrounds Historic NY Jan 30 #21
What rock did Gingrich crawl out from under at this late date to state the obvious? He is one of the reasons we are Martin68 Jan 30 #23
STFU newt. I wouldn't piss in his ear if his brain was on fire. Hassler Jan 30 #26
Yes he broke politics but maybe he can help unbreak them LearnedHand Jan 30 #27
This message was self-deleted by its author LudwigPastorius Jan 30 #30
Latest Discussions»Latest Breaking News»Gingrich: Time for 'natio...»Reply #29