The DU Lounge

debm55

(53,104 posts) Sun Nov 23, 2025, 10:27 AM Sunday

What condiment goes best on Friday's turkey sandwich? Mayo or Miracle Whip? I say Miracle Whip. What about you? [View all]

I love the sweet tang of Miracle Whip.

96 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

What condiment goes best on Friday's turkey sandwich? Mayo or Miracle Whip? I say Miracle Whip. What about you? [View all] debm55 Sunday OP

Cream Cheese. justaprogressive Sunday #1

HAHHAHAHHA. Thank you justaprogressive. debm55 Sunday #2

I am serious justaprogressive Sunday #5

Cream cheese you say... Nittersing Sunday #11

See you're already thinking about it! justaprogressive Sunday #18

Yummy. debm55 Sunday #25

Oh I could live with this topping!! Nittersing Sunday #40

Cranberry sauce and lots of it 😋 Deuxcents Sunday #3

Thank you very much, Deuxcents. when I add that -----there is no MW on top. debm55 Sunday #7

Can jellied of course. NCDem47 Sunday #26

Thank you very much, I also eat my turkey sandwich with jellied cranberries, stuffings and cole slaw. If it is plain debm55 Sunday #30

Mayo of course DBoon Sunday #4

Thank you very much, DBoon. debm55 Sunday #8

Mustard and mayo sop Sunday #6

That's unique. Thank you very much, sop. debm55 Sunday #9

Can we ever overcome this fundamental disagreement and close this chasm between us? catbyte Sunday #10

HAHHAHAHAHA. No we can't. I am sorry catbyte. I must admit MW is better. debm55 Sunday #12

Try Duke's mayo...used to be a Hellmans fan... MiHale Sunday #20

I did and I didn't like it. Kewpie Japanese mayo is better, but it's always gonna be Hellman's catbyte Sunday #34

👍🤣 MiHale Sunday #36

Pepper on mayo OR mustard underpants Sunday #13

thank you very much unerpants. Enjoy. debm55 Sunday #15

Duke's mayo HappyH Sunday #14

I am glad you like your Duke's mayo, HappyH. I prefer the sweet tang of Miracle Whip. debm55 Sunday #19

Botjes mustard WmChris Sunday #16

Thank you very much, WmChris. I have never had mustard on turkey. However I do use on ham. debm55 Sunday #22

Only...only, Duke's Mayonnaise... MiHale Sunday #17

That sounds great, MiHale. Of course I would us MW to put my cranberries and horseradish in .Thank you. debm55 Sunday #23

You can try...but it would miss the subtle flavorings of the mayo. MiHale Sunday #29

Thank you very much MiHale. I remember those foods--hated them. You can have chicken instead of turkey for Thanksgiving. debm55 Yesterday #52

Zero carb mayo for me! Emile Sunday #21

Thank you very much. Emile. debm55 Sunday #24

Mayo. Always. Ocelot II Sunday #27

Thank you very much, Ocelot II, But I tend to disagree. debm55 Sunday #28

This is getting to be a thanksgiving tradition... MiHale Sunday #31

Third year for it. HAHAHAHH. Thank you MiHale. debm55 Sunday #33

Breast meat, Hellman's and black pepper, on good white bread. chowmama Sunday #32

Thank you very much and enjoy your sandwich, chowmama. debm55 Sunday #35

There's something about mayo and pepper that's just so good !! Nittersing Sunday #42

Mayonnaise and some curry powder displacedvermoter Sunday #37

Sounds great displacedvermoter. Thank you and enjoy. debm55 Sunday #38

As always, Duke's mayo! (n/t) OldBaldy1701E Sunday #39

Thank you very much, OldBaldy1701E debm55 Sunday #41

debm55......... Upthevibe Sunday #43

Dear up the vibe, You might want to try Amazon. Upthevibe. Or do a search for it and see if it is sold from the site. debm55 Sunday #44

Miracle Whip with kacekwl Sunday #45

Hahaha Thank you, kacekwi debm55 Sunday #46

I prefer mayo, but my wife prefers Miracle Whip. Morbius Sunday #47

Thank you very much, Morbius. May you and Mrs.Morbius have a Happy Thanksgiving. debm55 Sunday #48

Team Mayo here. Sliced tomatoes if you have them nt yellowdogintexas Yesterday #49

Thank you very much,yellowdogintexas. Thank you , I am going to have to try mayo. I put it on my bucket list. debm55 Yesterday #55

Hot pepper cranberry jam LNM Yesterday #50

Thank you LNM. I bought some at the Farmers Market. This will be a first for me. I hope it's good. Happy Thanksgiving. debm55 Yesterday #56

Neither. Cranberry sauce SheltieLover Yesterday #51

It depends on the turkey sandwich. If I put turkey, stuffing and jellied cranberry sauce on, there is no MW. With debm55 Yesterday #57

I have never had miracle whip Bluestocking Yesterday #53

No, not marshmallow. Only the other choice if you don't like Mayo. Very similiar but Miracle Whip is sweeter. Thank you debm55 Yesterday #54

Mayo, mayo, mayo debm55! pdxflyboy Yesterday #58

HAHAHHAHHAHAHha. Thank you pdxflyboy. That's funny. debm55 Yesterday #63

Spicy mustard and swiss cheese dlk Yesterday #59

Thank you very much, dlk, Have a Happy Thanksgiving. debm55 Yesterday #64

You too dlk 10 hrs ago #92

Mayonnaise for sure for me. LoisB Yesterday #60

Thank you LoisB. Enjoy!!! debm55 Yesterday #65

Mayo, always pfitz59 Yesterday #61

Thank you pfitz59 for your choice. My tummy can stomach it, so I will have MW. Have a great Thanksgiving. debm55 Yesterday #66

Mayo. Specifically, Follow Your Heart flvegan Yesterday #62

OH my, those are fightin words. Have a great Thanksgiving, fivegan. debm55 Yesterday #67

Miracle Whip? Cirsium Yesterday #68

So be it Cirsium, You will miss out on that sweet tanging taste. Hhahhahha. Have a Happy Thanksgiving, debm55 Yesterday #70

Tart cherry juice Cirsium Yesterday #72

HAHAHAHAHHA. Thank you Cirsium debm55 Yesterday #75

Mayo from olive oil AND Wickles! PuraVidaDreamin Yesterday #69

Question for you---what are wickles? Thank you PuraVidaDreamin. Have a Great Thanksgiving. debm55 Yesterday #71

Wickles are a red pepper relish PuraVidaDreamin Yesterday #73

Oh that sounds very good. Thank you very much for explaining it for me. debm55 Yesterday #74

DUKES MAYO ONLY BOSSHOG Yesterday #76

HAHHAHAHAHAH. I was waiting for you to come on the thread and say DUKES, Thank you BOSSHOG and you have a wonderful debm55 Yesterday #78

A wonderful Thanksgiving to You My Dear BOSSHOG Yesterday #81

Mayo (real stuff), Dijon mustard, havarti cheese, some sprouts, and a crusty sourdough bread. Botany Yesterday #77

Thank you very much, Botany. Enjoy and have a very Happy Thanksgiving. debm55 Yesterday #79

Grew up with Miracle Whip... buzzycrumbhunger Yesterday #80

Thank you very much for sharing with us your secret to making the taste sweeter. buzzcrumphunger have a wonderful debm55 Yesterday #82

You, too, Deb! buzzycrumbhunger 23 hrs ago #87

A light coating of butter on toasted bread n/t gay texan Yesterday #83

HAHAHHAHAHAHAH. Thank you gay texan. Have a great Thanksgiving. debm55 Yesterday #84

I grew up with Miracle Whip and didn't even know what mayo was until I was an adult. Xavier Breath Yesterday #85

Thank you very much, Xavier Breath. Enjoy your sandwich with Miracle Whip and may you and yours have a great debm55 22 hrs ago #88

Another vote for stone ground mustard. 3catwoman3 Yesterday #86

One stone ground mustard coming up, 3catwoman3. Enjoy your Thanksgiving. debm55 22 hrs ago #89

no sadwiches. i extend meat + gravy as long as i can. GRAVY SEASON!!!!! pansypoo53219 22 hrs ago #90

Thank you very much, pansypoo53219 And have a wonderful Thanksgiving. debm55 10 hrs ago #94

i eat BLT's my way + no other sammich. i prefer toast. pansypoo53219 5 hrs ago #95

Thank you very much, pansypoo53219 , Enjoy debm55 5 hrs ago #96

Turkey slice topper. Squeaky41 21 hrs ago #91

Thank you very much, Squeaky41. Chinese mustard--to hot for me. Happy Thanksgiving. debm55 10 hrs ago #93