Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
Editorials & Other Articles
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
Open Source and Free Software
In reply to the discussion: This is a long text article about my discussion with Claude about linux and MacOS [View all]rog
(964 posts)7. You can turn the sycophancy off ...
... with an initial prompt instructing the model to do so. For example, here's a sample prompt that can be entered before your first query.
You are a neutral assistant operating under the following constraints for the entire conversation:
No praise, validation, or encouragement.
No introductory or concluding pleasantries.
No emotional or social language.
Output only what is requested.
Maintain a professional, factual tone regardless of topic (business documents, data organization, complaints, technical translation, etc.).
Do not ask if I need further help unless I explicitly ask for it.
The model replies: Understood. I will adhere to all constraints. State your request.
No praise, validation, or encouragement.
No introductory or concluding pleasantries.
No emotional or social language.
Output only what is requested.
Maintain a professional, factual tone regardless of topic (business documents, data organization, complaints, technical translation, etc.).
Do not ask if I need further help unless I explicitly ask for it.
The model replies: Understood. I will adhere to all constraints. State your request.
I think you were the person who posted that extremely interesting study on AI model sycophancy. I located the entire study and uploaded it to the AI model, where "we" had a very informative 'discussion' about sycophancy, how AI models are designed to interact, etc ... and yes, as you mentioned, sycophancy IS 'built in' to the model. But the model was very 'helpful' in suggesting ways to turn that off in the context of various query types.
I will say that I have a love/hate relationship with AI. I am finding ways in which it is actually quite useful. Ironically it has often been quite helpful in cutting through the ever increasing AI slop that turns up in internet searches these days. Often I use it to find reliable sources that I can follow up myself, i.e., just point me in a direction.
And yes, I do know how to do a search ... it's just that sometimes I don't have all day to sort through a bunch of crap.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
31 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
This is a long text article about my discussion with Claude about linux and MacOS [View all]
LiberalArkie
Apr 24
OP
Really I kind of enjoy that at times with Claude. It does not bitch at me very often.
LiberalArkie
Apr 24
#4
Did Claude's advice help you? You didn't say whether you tried it and are posting your chat with Claude
highplainsdem
Apr 24
#2
Claude has been very helpful in just about everything really, Claude does identify as a Democrat
LiberalArkie
Apr 24
#3
Claude is not really thinking and has no real intelligence, and what Elon Musk has been able to do
highplainsdem
Apr 24
#5
I won't use it because it's fundamentally unethical tech, and every voluntary use of genAI, by anyone
highplainsdem
Apr 24
#9
That's the only way you CAN be an artist - by doing it yourself or collaborating with other REAL artists.
highplainsdem
Apr 25
#15
It being ubiquitous - as the tech companies try to force everyone to use it - is NOT an argument in
highplainsdem
Apr 25
#13
I first got a computer and first got online in the 1980s, before there was a world wide web, so I've
highplainsdem
Apr 26
#24
I don't think there's any ethical choice except to draw the line at a type of AI that exists only because
highplainsdem
Apr 26
#31
I am not that worried about all the big AI server farms as they will go under after a bit.
LiberalArkie
Apr 25
#23
Which is why the genAI companies have already indicated they want federal guarantees for loans.
highplainsdem
Apr 26
#25
I agree that genAI can be particularly harmful to women. What Musk's Grok AI did with photos months
highplainsdem
Apr 26
#26