Israel/Palestine

lapucelle

(20,767 posts)

12. The claim appears to be that it was a targeted attack on Hamdi Al-Najjar via "Where's Daddy?".

Reply to Beastly Boy (Reply #8)

Mon May 26, 2025, 06:37 AM

May 2025

Why would the doctor's husband be targeted?

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

Beastly Boy

85 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Israeli strike kills nine of Gaza doctor's children, hospital says [View all] AloeVera May 2025 OP

An AI-detected target walks into a residence, and a smart bomb hits it. John1956PA May 2025 #1

"Where's Daddy" was developed by the Israeli military and has been in use in Gaza since the beginning of the war. AloeVera May 2025 #2

Isn't it the same hospital on whose grounds three top Hamas commanders, including Mohammad Sinwar, the leader of Hamas Beastly Boy May 2025 #3

You're wrong as always. AloeVera May 2025 #6

Other than your presumptive assertions, there is nothing you can produce to challenge me. Beastly Boy May 2025 #8

The claim appears to be that it was a targeted attack on Hamdi Al-Najjar via "Where's Daddy?". lapucelle May 2025 #12

They ran out of claims that appear halfass legitimate. An outright illegitimate one will do just fine Beastly Boy May 2025 #13

See post 14. AloeVera May 2025 #15

What's interesting is that lapucelle May 2025 #35

Israel started bombing on evening of Oct 7th. AloeVera May 2025 #37

Like I said, I don't get my news from tiktok. N/T lapucelle May 2025 #43

He is a doctor too. AloeVera May 2025 #14

Healthcare workers like this guy? "Journalist, doctor held Israelis hostage in Gaza" lapucelle May 2025 #36

So all healthcare workers and their children are guilty? AloeVera May 2025 #38

A doctor holding hostages in a residential building is disgusting. lapucelle May 2025 #41

This is a grotesque logical fallacy Picaro Jun 2025 #77

Exactly. Two things can be true at the same time. NH Ethylene Jun 2025 #78

"Taking a specific incident and generalizing it to condemn an entire population"... lapucelle Jun 2025 #79

Please elucidate. Picaro Jun 2025 #80

My background is in education. Students learn best when they figure things out for themselves. lapucelle Jun 2025 #81

Snide aren't you--even when you're wrong Picaro Jun 2025 #82

Your profile says that you're from Plano, Texas. lapucelle Jun 2025 #83

You just crossed into trollland Picaro Jun 2025 #84

You said you're from Missouri. You're the one who brought it up. lapucelle Jun 2025 #85

Geneva does not authorize going hog-wild in an orgy of destruction on hospitals. AloeVera May 2025 #19

Geneva does not authorize the use of hospitals for harboring top belligerent commanders. Beastly Boy May 2025 #24

None of it excuses going hog-wild in an orgy of destruction... AloeVera May 2025 #25

Yes, for some reason "going hog-wild in an orgy of destruction" is not in the Geneva conventions at all. Beastly Boy May 2025 #26

If you truly believe Israel's destruction of health care and hospitals AloeVera May 2025 #27

I believe nothing. The Geneva conventions are not a religious text to believe or disbelieve. Beastly Boy May 2025 #28

Oh and... the house where the kids burned to death was 3 miles from the hospital grounds. AloeVera May 2025 #7

So it wasn't an *attack* terrorists hiding in a hospital? The claim is that it was a targeted attack lapucelle May 2025 #11

The Hamas bigwigs were hiding underground in the tunnel under the European Hospital. lapucelle May 2025 #9

What does that have to do with the strike 3 miles away on a civilian house? AloeVera May 2025 #16

That was terrorist stronghold in a different hospital. You pointed that out, remember? lapucelle May 2025 #17

Huh? Lol AloeVera May 2025 #20

Upthread when you got into a quibble about the hospital tunnels where Mohammed Sinwar and the murder videographer lapucelle May 2025 #21

Post #3 ? That was not me... AloeVera May 2025 #23

Read yor response. N/T lapucelle May 2025 #29

Photo of her nine kids prepared for burial.... riversedge May 2025 #4

Oh no... AloeVera May 2025 #5

Yes. Hamas needs to release the remaining hostages and hostage bodies, surrender, and beg lapucelle May 2025 #10

Never mind terrorist organizations use civilians as human shields. That doesn't enter the equation at all because AZLD4Candidate May 2025 #18

Looks like the only side proven to use human shields is Israel. AloeVera May 2025 #22

When Jewish lives are treated with such reverance, maybe I'll change my mind AZLD4Candidate May 2025 #42

In all probability this is yet another lie. Richard D May 2025 #30

This is the second time these children have been killed. Richard D May 2025 #31

Appalling. There were nine real, alive children burned and mutilated to death. That is indisputable. AloeVera May 2025 #33

Says . . . Richard D May 2025 #34

You keep repeating 44,000 when that falsehood was called out already. AloeVera May 2025 #39

UN lying about 44,000 children dying in 48 hours? Never happened! Beastly Boy May 2025 #44

Oh and you are back on ignore. AloeVera May 2025 #40

I'll do my best Richard D May 2025 #45

Pictures lie and reveal Richard D May 2025 #46

According to the article posted by the OP, it was a targeted strike on the father, a Hamas militant terrorist. lapucelle May 2025 #49

Damn . . . Richard D May 2025 #50

Either way the story stinks to high heaven. lapucelle May 2025 #53

Which article was that in? Violet_Crumble Jun 2025 #62

+972 Magazine. lapucelle Jun 2025 #64

The 972mag article doesn't say that at all... Violet_Crumble Jun 2025 #65

No, that's who the +972 magazine piece says are targeted. lapucelle Jun 2025 #67

The 972mag article doesn't say anything about the father recently killed... Violet_Crumble Jun 2025 #68

Actually, it's an inference based on evidence that the OP so helpfully provided. lapucelle Jun 2025 #69

So, it's nothing but yr opinion. Okay. Violet_Crumble Jun 2025 #70

Just trying to be pro-active.... Because of course the IDF would claim that "terrorists" were there! AloeVera Jun 2025 #73

Gaza is full of terrorists. lapucelle Jun 2025 #74

Then Israel is the King of Terror. AloeVera Jun 2025 #75

Thanks.... AloeVera Jun 2025 #72

It is not a lie that the children were killed. Even your source says that. AloeVera May 2025 #32

That would be a treat NoRethugFriends May 2025 #47

Because the story in the OP is raising so many red flags, it is likely a lie. Beastly Boy May 2025 #48

$20 billion in 2024 in aid alone from U.S. to Israel. Duncanpup May 2025 #51

We didn't give $20 billion dollars in aid to Israel in 2024. N/T lapucelle May 2025 #55

Heartbreaking 💔 Goddessartist May 2025 #52

Heartbreaking responses can be made to disappear . AloeVera May 2025 #54

Sigh Israeli May 2025 #56

Thanks... AloeVera May 2025 #57

Regarding : Israeli Jun 2025 #58

Very encouraging!! AloeVera Jun 2025 #59

So much could be avoided if Israeli Jun 2025 #60

Yep. Violet_Crumble Jun 2025 #61

Wow, that's exactly what it is. AloeVera Jun 2025 #63

That one gets trotted out quite regularly, accompanied by dit-dits around Palestinians... Violet_Crumble Jun 2025 #66

"Why are those children there"? WTAF! AloeVera Jun 2025 #71

More war crimes Picaro Jun 2025 #76