Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News Editorials & Other Articles General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

wnylib

(25,259 posts)
19. No, cats do not have expressive vocal language
Tue Oct 24, 2023, 05:48 AM
Oct 2023

Last edited Tue Oct 24, 2023, 06:27 AM - Edit history (1)

that people can decode. I was not suggesting that they do. But cats and some other animals do have some limited receptive language ability. They don't use sounds to communicate that are consistent across their species, with structures like grammar and syntax, as far as anyone currently knows. But that might be due only to biological limits on the ranges of sounds that they can make. They have intent to "say" or communicate something, but without the range of sounds to express themselves in structured language, they use combinations of body language and sounds to get their meaning across to people.

But they do recognize and respond to single and some multiple words spoken to them. They have the ability to comprehend the meaning of some human sounds addressed to them. That's receptive language comprehension. It's limited to concrete, demonstrable words like nouns and verbs. When Ember understands the meaning of a word from me, she responds to the word no matter who says it.

Dogs generally have a greater receptive language capacity than cats. (Or a greater willingness to "admit" that they understand a word.) Anyone who has lived with a border collie can tell you how astonishing their ability to pick up word meanings is, even without attempts to teach them.

I have read animal behaviorists' statements that cats do not use vocal sounds to communicate to each other, that they only try to do it with people because people use sounds. But I love this old video from about 20 years ago.






Recommendations

1 members have recommended this reply (displayed in chronological order):

They did, for dogs anyway: ret5hd Oct 2023 #1
There are folks doing it with talking buttons jmbar2 Oct 2023 #2
Because animals know better than to talk to jerks like humans. Orrex Oct 2023 #3
Hear Hear! OldBaldy1701E Oct 2023 #16
AI will do it intrepidity Oct 2023 #4
Are you sure we want to find out? Turbineguy Oct 2023 #5
There is an app. Apparently it works only for the English language. Marcuse Oct 2023 #6
Animals don't have "language" as such, in the sense of having a structure Ocelot II Oct 2023 #7
Great explanation... Think. Again. Oct 2023 #8
interesting Grasswire2 Oct 2023 #9
But that's just one-way language understanding. Ocelot II Oct 2023 #10
but how do we know that? Grasswire2 Oct 2023 #13
Here is a good explanation in terms of linguistics and cat behavior: Ocelot II Oct 2023 #14
See the video in my #19. wnylib Oct 2023 #21
We actually don't know if that is accurate anymore. Voltaire2 Oct 2023 #15
But cats can understand words. So, they are able to wnylib Oct 2023 #17
Your cat understands some words, but is your cat saying actual words Ocelot II Oct 2023 #18
No, cats do not have expressive vocal language wnylib Oct 2023 #19
The woman who posted this video to You Tube wnylib Oct 2023 #20
If brain functions are translated I_UndergroundPanther Oct 2023 #26
Temple Grandin, an expert on animal behavior who is on the autism spectrum, Ocelot II Oct 2023 #27
Have you heard about Bunny? vanlassie Oct 2023 #11
Can't see it. I'm not on Facebook. Can you describe it? wnylib Oct 2023 #22
Web site: vanlassie Oct 2023 #23
Thanks. wnylib Oct 2023 #24
You can't trust anything my cat would say anyway. LOL n/t brewens Oct 2023 #12
I would be so happy if this could be invented I_UndergroundPanther Oct 2023 #25
Noooo! JackSabbath Oct 2023 #28
Humans always need to conquer everything Deuxcents Oct 2023 #29
My dog certainly understands a lot of language. I am resonalbly sure that she could speak English if she Chainfire Oct 2023 #30
Latest Discussions»Culture Forums»Pets»Why, I wonder, has scienc...»Reply #19